Review of Alice Underground

To describe Dark Horse Theatre‘s Alice Underground is tricky business without giving too much of the play away. On the other hand, one would be hard pressed to say exactly what does take place in this visually lush, creatively rich, brilliantly-acted performance.

If you haven’t already reserved tickets for the play’s final two shows — tonight (Friday, March 12) and tomorrow (Saturday, March 13) at the BeBe Theatre (20 Commerce St., Asheville), 8 p.m. both nights — you might be out of luck since the entire run is sold out. It’s worth getting your name on the wait list, though, since any unclaimed tickets are released at 7:50 p.m. Info: 279-4449.

If you have reserved tickets, fasten your seat belt: This hour and nine-minute show is quite a ride. Even before the play starts, BeBe Theater is rife with atmosphere. Lounge-y, downtempo music washes over the room, black and white sketches of the Alice in Wonderland characters adorn the walls. Lights come up to reveal the cast, all in pirate-disco-Steam Punk-Vaudeville-Edward Gorey-style attire — gathered in a dysfunctional cluster around Alice — played to gorgeous, dazed-and-confused perfection by Sarah Carpenter — who stands atop a trunk clutching a suitcase in one hand and a white parasol (that would delight Lemony Snicket and Holiday Childress alike) in the other. All of the characters talk over each other, one stream-of-consciousness/random/nonsensical line bleeding into the next. If this seems utterly disorienting, it’s only the beginning.

The point of Alice in Wonderland — the original book by English author Lewis Carroll — is that Alice falls into a rabbit hole and has adventures in the very disorienting and bizarre world below ground. In Dark Horse’s Alice, the audience actually participates in Alice’s confusion, bombarded with double talk, an array of unstrung characters and situation after maddeningly strange situation. To make sense of it all … well, that’s not going to happen. To watch the play is sort of like looking at one of those 3-D optical illusion posters. If you try too hard, you won’t see the image. If you relax and just go with it, all will be revealed. Sort of.

Tom Chalmers’ Duchess is played to a shrill paragon; Bradshaw Call’s White Rabbit (happily free of floppy ears, puffy tail or anything too literal) is a study in hand-wringing anxiety, Marissa Williams (full disclosure: she’s also Xpress’ retail advertising representative and web & marketing manager) plays both a groovy one-toke-over-the-line caterpillar (again, thankfully no insect parts to her costume) and a sultry/chilling Studio 54 version of the Queen of Hearts. Delina Hensley’s Cheshire Cat is the show’s coolest, most level headed character — and pulls off an excellent fedora-rolling trick — while Emily Miller’s Baby Jane-meets-Little Edie Beale White Queen is a schizophrenic delight. Jeremy Carter turns in two of the shows most disturbingly sexy roles, as the leather pantsed Mad Hatter and the flaming feather boa-ed Pansy.

Though based on the Lewis Carroll adventure, Alice Underground takes many liberties. And good for them; there’s the Johnny Depp movie out right now which does the same (in a totally different way), and since the original book was published in 1865, everyone and his brother had produced a version. My opinion: No one really needs another Disney version. That said, this Alice is probably not appropriate for kids and it might be helpful to have at least a basic knowledge of the characters and plot from the original Alice. (Then again, my husband, who claims not to know the original story, loved the show.)

The original story — rather like “Puff the Magic Dragon” — has been subject to decades of speculation about the actual meaning. Symbols of math and history can be found throughout, but it’s the potential allusions to death (falling down the rabbit hole) and drugs (“Eat me,” “drink me,” the hookah-smoking caterpillar) that grip the collective conscience. Dark Horse chose to focus on those darkly enticing ideas, and to largely successful affect. The overall bar is raised even farther by some excellent black and white video footage shot by Peter Brezny in which Carpenter’s Alice walks — and falls from — a tightrope over a city.

The show, in its entirety, is a stylish, moody, ambient dream with no downtime. The cavelike setting of BeBe’s black box theater adds to the underground feel, but ultimately it’s the fantastic costumes, fully-committed acting and fun script that make this a memorable evening. Dear Dark Horse: Schedule another run soon.

—Alli Marshall


About Alli Marshall
Alli Marshall is the arts section editor at Mountain Xpress. She's lived in Asheville for more than 20 years and loves live music, visual art, fiction and friendly dogs. Alli is the winner of the 2016 Thomas Wolfe Fiction Prize and the author of the novel "How to Talk to Rockstars," published by Logosophia Books. Follow me @alli_marshall

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

6 thoughts on “Review of Alice Underground

  1. Julie C

    Be nice if some extra shows could be added. I would love to see this one!

  2. I agree Julie. This show was fantastic – original material, witty, well acted and thought-provoking. Dark Horse Theatre has a facebook page. Perhaps you can go there and bug them. I suggest a lot of people bug them for extra performances.

  3. Theatre Goer

    Saw this titillatingly bizarre romp and absolutely loved it! The costumer’s name escapes me, but what credit they deserve!

  4. Joseph Barcia

    For those who are curious, the actors took care of their own costumes, and the director gave us a “yes” or “no” to individual pieces we brought.

  5. we’re hoping to add more shows to ‘alice underground’ if we can find a performance space to hold us! we’ll let you know if we are able to do so.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.