October Baby

Movie Information

The Story: An adopted girl goes searching for her birth mother. The Lowdown: Better looking (at least some of the time) than most faith-based movies and with a standout small turn from Jasmine Guy, but strictly of interest to a very specific demographic.
Genre: Faith-based Drama
Director: Andrew Erwin, Jon Erwin
Starring: Rachel Hendrix, Jason Burkey, John Schneider, Jasmine Guy, Jennifer Price, Shari Wiedmann
Rated: PG-13

What we have here is the latest faith-based opus to make it to mainstream release. As is usual with these things, October Baby is aimed strictly and directly at the folks who already buy into what it’s selling. This one has a pro-life slant, and a tenuous connection to the faith-based film factory known as the Sherwood Baptist Church, in that co-director Jon Erwin served as second-unit director on the church’s movie from last year, Courageous. He and brother Andrew, however, also have a history of direct-to-video offerings, and these have somehow never crossed my path. The IMDb is littered with “reviews” about how great October Baby is, all from people who have otherwise never posted anything there before.

Following this review, I suspect I will be on the receiving end of at least one e-mail from someone who is going to pray for me. Now, if they can explain to me why “if you enjoyed this title,” the IMDb suggests you might also like Away We Go, Gone with the Wind, Juno, Click and, more mystifying yet, Joy Ride, I’d be happy to hear from them. I’m honestly a little perplexed why the distributor is soliciting critics’ responses—this is unlikely to end well.

The story is all about Hannah (Rachel Hendrix), who, after she collapses while doing a play, finds out that she’s adopted and was born prematurely as the result of a botched abortion. While I can see how this might have some connection to her physical health, I’m less sold on the film’s notion that the trauma of this has impacted her mental health, but I’m willing to go with it. Naturally, this sends her on a search for her birth mother and a large serving of family drama—mostly involving her fighting with her father (John Schneider, of all people). So, of course, she teams up with her not-really-boyfriend Jason (Jason Burkey) on some spring-vacation excursion that turns into a hunt for her birth mother. There’s a good deal of low-grade comedy here—a lot of it centered on saving one’s self for marriage.

What follows is no more surprising than you might expect—certainly no more so that I expected—and every bit as melodramatic. Leads Hendrix and Burkey are adequate, I suppose. At least, they’re pretty good at looking sincere. But the acting honors here definitely go to Jasmine Guy, who manages to make her character—the nurse who delivered Hannah and who knows the truth—actually believable, likable and even moving. I have to give her and the movie credit in this regard, because this is the first time I’ve had an emotional response (at least the intended one) to any of these movies. That the film later insists on having Guy, Schneider and Jennifer Price (as Hannah’s adoptive mother) play themselves 18 years earlier is another—and far more ludicrous—matter.

I’ll also concede that the direction—at least in the early sections of the film at the play—is considerably more visually creative than I’m used to seeing in faith-based movies. Later on, the direction tends to degenerate into a style that can only be called “goopy greeting card basic,” but it’s obvious that Jon Erwin (who also served as cinematographer) has a grasp of how to shoot a movie, even though he has a tendency towards cliches. That the whole thing is absolutely flooded in undistinguished Christian pop tunes, and it has one of those scores that primarily leans on “emotive” chords (Tyler Perry is big on these). In the end, it’s strictly for its target audience, who tend to be very uncritical where these movies are concerned. Rated PG-13 for mature thematic material.


About Ken Hanke
Head film critic for Mountain Xpress from December 2000 until his death in June 2016. Author of books "Ken Russell's Films," "Charlie Chan at the Movies," "A Critical Guide to Horror Film Series," "Tim Burton: An Unauthorized Biography of the Filmmaker."

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

6 thoughts on “October Baby

  1. Brian Roberts

    Ken, I saw this film in a preview version, so it’s possible the cut you saw was different than the one I did, but unless I’m mistaken the scene you took as Jasmine Guy and Schneider’s characters 18 years earlier was not a flashback; The scene was an epilogue that showed that Jasmine guy’s nurse character had gone back to nursing, and the baby was the child of the police officer that gave Burkey and Hendrix the nurse’s contact information. He remembered the nurse (Jasmine Guy), and had spoken about how his wife was pregnant. I don’t know if this changes your opinion of the film, but that small scene of quiet redemption was actually the most impactful in the film for me.

  2. Bert

    There’s a much more interesting “faith based” film called Blue Like Jazz coming out next month. Based on the book, about a Texas evangelical who experiences a spiritual crises and moves to Portland, Oregon. The Christian film community(whatever that is) is supposedly deeply uncomfortable and unsupportive of the film. I’ve heard the trailer was supposed to air before October Baby but is being yanked a lot of places.

  3. Ken Hanke

    I don’t know if this changes your opinion of the film

    If that’s what it is, it removes what struck me as a really bad idea, but it doesn’t change my overall opinion of the movie.

  4. Ken Hanke

    The Christian film community(whatever that is) is supposedly deeply uncomfortable and unsupportive of the film. I’ve heard the trailer was supposed to air before October Baby but is being yanked a lot of places.

    That’s interesting. It probably means that the film will get little or no play and will almost certainly tank, since these movies rely on being pushed by churches. I’m still perplexed as to why they went out of their way to solicit reviews from the secular media. The results have been what I’d expect (I’m kinder to it than most) and pretty slim.

  5. Bert

    I’ve read the book Blue Like Jazz. It’s basically an evangelical whose faith leads him to befriend secularists, atheists, artists, gays, lesbians. And he spends as much time listening to their worldview and stories as he does trying to convert them. So could make for an interesting film, but doesn’t fit comfortably in the Kirk Cameron model.

  6. Ken Hanke

    And how does that work out for him? The thing that makes me uncomfortable with the film sight unseen is that the IMDb is awash with people who have never previously felt compelled to post anything waxing ecstatic over how wonderful it is.

Leave a Reply to Ken Hanke ×

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.