Here’s the plan for Asheville’s Downtown Master Plan

“We do work with cities all over the country, and we have to think of every community as very distinct, and at the same time shaped by shared sets of opportunities and challenges,” says David Dixon, leader of the team picked to create a new Downtown Master Plan for “growth and sustainability” over the next 10 years in Asheville. “This will be particularly important for Asheville, because it’s such a literally, richly diverse community.”

Dixon directs planning and urban design for Goody Clancy, the Boston-based firm selected by an advisory committee of city and county staff and Downtown Commission members on Feb. 8. The $170,000 contract was on the Feb. 19 City Council agenda; if approved, the consultants will start gathering information next month and begin holding public events in April. The target date for completing the plan is late October.

“This plan for downtown will be a transportation plan, a small-business retention-and-development plan … a historic preservation plan, a tourism [and] sort of an economic opportunity plan,” Dixon says.

The first step will be interviews involving a cross section of the community, “so we can get a gut-level sense of what is important to people, and what is driving the kind of decisions that they want out of this process,” explains the planner. “What are the anxieties, opportunities, challenges?”

The next step: a community-engagement process that Dixon calls “absolutely critical” in order to create a plan that is “great from many perspectives at the same time.” The objective is to “create situations in which people are talking and we are learning, and they’re learning from us.”

Dixon says past Goody Clancy projects have offered numerous lessons in the ways different communities perceive and respond to—or don’t respond to—challenges that they share, emphasizing that cities are shaped around constituencies that look at issues differently. Developers may be geared around a relatively short timeframe based on financing, whereas a university planning the revitalization of a neighborhood may be thinking on a 100-year span. An elected official may only consider two to four years—the election cycle. The planner’s task, he says, it to incorporate all of those perspectives.

Dixon’s work has also involved planning for heritage tourism, a sector actively pursued in Asheville. His team includes Mary Means and Associates of Alexandria, Va., creator of the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s Main Street program, and the Asheville-based Heritage Directions, which specializes in heritage development.

In Dixon’s opinion, well-managed cultural—or heritage—tourism means attracting people who don’t come “just to go to great bars.” They’re likely to “spend more money” than the average tourist and be “much more interested in what is authentic about a place.” Heritage development, he asserts, contributes to stronger wages and offers opportunities for “people who have no intention of living conventional lives,” such as artists for whom such tourism provides a market.

Dixon will also focus on the “nonfranchise retail economy” and the role of local entrepreneurs. “There are all sorts of examples across the country—and Asheville is a terrific one—of places that have found ways to mediate between the challenge of promoting locally based small businesses and the desirability to do that,” he says.

Goody Clancy’s proposal to the city cited Asheville’s “unique character” and pledged to work toward attracting new investment, residents and visitors while promoting a sustainable environment.

For additional information, contact Sasha Vrtunski, the city’s project manager, at or 232-4599.


Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

4 thoughts on “Here’s the plan for Asheville’s Downtown Master Plan

  1. I wonder – will there be a citizen board of review who will be working with the city and Goody Clancy? How are they planning on reaching out and working with the community?

  2. Matt Mercy

    Delphi technique: The city council already has a plan and agenda. What it is, who knows…but its probably bad.

    The public input sessions are where the consultants come in and steer the citizens toward that pre-determined agenda and then convince those citizens that they have ownership of the plan…that they came up with a good solution to certain problems. Again, the “solutions” were decided a long time before public discourse takes place. “Consultant” is another word for “agenda salesman”.

  3. Matt –
    That is just plain not true.

    While the council has adopted key strategies of issues that are important to them (such as green energy) this process of making a master plan is supposed to be VERY much community based.
    These guys are hired with OUR taxes to take OUR ideas, issues, opinions and goals and decipher them into a plan WE want.

    I’m sorry to see you are so untrustworthy of the process. If you’d like to prove me wrong, feel free to come to one of the many upcoming public meetings:

    If you don’t come, then it’d probably be best for you to stop assuming the nature of the beast that really isn’t all that beastly.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.