In a tumultuous election year, with Republicans seeking to regain control of Congress, North Carolina's 11th Congressional District is an appealing target. Comprising both urban, Democratic Asheville and the more Republican-leaning surrounding counties, the district is rated “Republican +6” by the Cook Partisan Voting Index.

Incumbent Heath Shuler, a conservative Blue Dog Democrat, is fighting for a third term. The former Washington Redskins quarterback crushed his last Republican challenger, former Asheville City Council member Carl Mumpower, in 2008. But after siding with Republicans in opposing health-care-reform legislation and the repeal of the “don't ask, don't tell” policy, Shuler made a surprisingly weak showing against unknown opponent Aixa Wilson in the primary.

Challenger Jeff Miller, a Hendersonville businessman, is best known for starting the HonorAir program, which flies veterans to Washington, D.C., to visit the World War II Memorial. Miller emerged from a six-sided electoral brawl in the GOP primary, narrowly avoiding a runoff.

Shuler has collected endorsements from the Sierra Club and the National Education Association; the GOP, meanwhile, has tagged Miller as one of its up-and-coming “young guns,” and the Republican-leaning group Americans for Job Security is spending $712,000 on ads attacking Shuler.

Miller himself, though, says he hadn't considered running until veterans he'd met through HonorAir, as well as his son's high-school friends, urged him to do so.

“It was weird to have these bookend generations approaching me at the same time with similar concerns,” he notes. “We've got to get people back to work. Look at everything that's wrong right now: It usually goes back to people not having jobs.”

These days, that word is looming large in every candidate’s message. Shuler says his main issue is “job creation and our economy, along with debt and the deficit. We've got to close tax loopholes that help these companies that ship jobs overseas, and focus on encouraging manufacturing jobs. Clean energy is one big way we can do that, to give us independence from the Middle East.”

Miller likewise says he plans to go after “the national deficit. … That's a nonpartisan concern.” His approach, however, differs from Shuler's.

“Whatever stimulus money was left, whatever TARP funds we got back, would go to paying that down, as well as really cutting spending,” says the challenger, adding that he blames both parties for the rise in spending. Asked for specifics, Miller says, “Everything except, initially, defense and veterans’ benefits would be up for scrutiny.” He also advocates a freeze on federal hiring and raises, along with “less taxes and less unreasonable requirements.”

Miller cautions: “I don't have some vision of a mass whack on any one department; I don't think that's practical. But the growth has been unreasonable, and we can do more with less.”

Defense and entitlement spending, however, account for a big chunk of the federal budget, and contrary to what some of Shuler's ads claim, Miller declares: “That's a promise we've made and have to keep. I am in no way in favor of being part of anything that goes after Social Security,” though he does advocate “removing the waste and the fraud.”

Shuler, meanwhile, says we should “conduct government more like a business. You can't just borrow the money from the Chinese or print money.” He points to his role in passing pay-as-you-go rules for proposed legislation.

Having voted with Republicans on major initiatives and taken stands on abortion and immigration that aren't far from the Republican platform, Shuler explains: “I always vote for my district. I look at the policy, not the party.”

And though Shuler opposed the health-care-reform bill, he says he wouldn’t seek to repeal it, because he supports things like preventing insurance companies from denying coverage to people with pre-existing conditions.

Asked where his positions differ from Miller’s, Shuler cites “our energy and environmental policies. … I want to build our economy back, and I feel clean energy is a matter of national security. The U.S. consumes 25 percent of the world's petroleum; we have less than 3 percent of the world's reserves. We have to find alternatives, and clean alternatives. The Chinese have just put in $700 billion to find new, innovative technologies. It's time for us to start building things back in America. Our energy policy threatens our defense and our environment.”

For his part, Miller says he doesn't oppose “reasonable [environmental] regulation,” supports “managing forests” as a balance between business and environmental interests, and would have liked to see stimulus funds go to maintaining and improving the Blue Ridge Parkway. But the candidates differ on proposed climate-change legislation, which Shuler has supported.

And over time, the rhetoric has become more heated. Attack ads from Shuler's campaign have blasted Miller as beholden to “special interests” and Wall Street; meanwhile, Miller's campaign has painted Shuler's as “lies” “more lies” and, in one case, “a sad trail of lies harder to follow than a flea flicker.”

Shuler says: “I haven't watched any of his commercials, so I've yet to see. I have a very young family; we try not to put them in that situation. In desperate times, people will say anything.”

Miller says the candidates had agreed to forswear negative campaigning, but that Shuler “came out and attacked me with what was false. I asked him to stop; their response was saying I should quit whining. It's just gotten more negative since that. I'll never do anything but tell the truth.”

Campaigns aside, Shuler says the difference between the two candidates boils down to “leadership: an ability to work with both sides of the aisle. I've been … chair of the National Prayer Breakfast, chair of the subcommittee on small business, leadership of Blue Dog caucus. It's going to take some strong leadership to get us forward; it's going to take someone willing to work across party lines, and I've proven that.”

— David Forbes can be reached at 251-1333, ext. 137, or at


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

5 thoughts on “Crossroads

  1. UnaffiliatedVoter

    Shuler is reported to be in Memphis TN today attending a FUNDRAISER. Most of Shuler’s donations have come from OUTSIDE the voting district and from major PACs and UNIONs…

    Millers donations have largely come from INDIVIDUALs from WITHIN the voting district!

    WHO do YOU trust?

  2. I don’t trust either Shuler or Miller to advance my values in the political marketplace regardless of where their campaign money comes from.

  3. Dionysis

    A quick peek at other national races with teabagger candidates and others offers some interesting insights.

    “Christine O’Donnell…has admitted to using campaign funds to pay part of the rent on her townhouse…O’Donnell’s financial past includes a tax lien from the IRS, a lawsuit from the university she attended over unpaid bills and a foreclosure action that she avoided by selling her house to her former campaign attorney before a sheriff’s auction.”

    In a debate with her rival Chris Coons, she claimed there was no reference to any separation of church and state in the Constitution.

    When asked by the moderator to name specific examples of liberal laws she claimed were ruining the country, she could not name one, and even asked the moderator to identify one and she’d “comment on it.”

    But she knows how the country can get its fiscal house in order!

    “A Republican congressional candidate in Texas who once likened the US government to Nazi Germany went even further Thursday when he said a violent overthrow is “on the table.”

    Stephen Broden also stated “In a 2009 interview with Fox News, Broden said that depopulation was the real agenda of the new health care law.”

    “A new report by a leading veterans group has awarded grades to members of Congress based on their support of veterans issues. One party failed miserably…that 92 percent of the D and F grades went to members of the GOP.

    Of the 94 congressmen that received A or A+ grades, 91 are Democrats and three are Republicans.”

    But Republicans claim Democrats “don’t support the troops.”

    As much fun as the local races are, they seem to pale in comparison to some of the whacko extremists in other races.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.