A problem of money: Commissioners face mental-health shortfall, delay 911 agreement

At its meeting last night, the Buncombe County Board of Commissioners unanimously passed a resolution condemning state attempts to raid local mental-health-fund balances to meet North Carolina’s own budget shortage. Such a loss would leave more mentally ill people in jails or hospitals for lack of proper treatment, county officials said.

“These our local dollars earned through careful management,” Department of Social Services Director Mandy Stone told the board of the mental-health move. “If the state takes our fund-balance dollars, we’ll have no dollars to spend locally to fill gaps.”

Taking away the local fund balance would gut the Western Highlands Network’s programs in several areas, including crisis teams, programs to provide psychiatric help to rural residents and lab tests for indigent mentally ill people, among other vital programs, Stone said. The network covers eight counties, including Buncombe, Madison and Henderson and cooperates with many local agencies.

It would also compound an already worsening situation, as Stone noted that the state has not paid its share of local mental-health funds — some $4.4 million — for the last two months.

“We would not be able to make up that gap without our fund balance — and now they want to take that too,” she said. “This is an area where the state turned over responsibility for managing mental health to local entities and since has been steadily taking away any tools we have to effectively do that. We’d have to reduce services by $1.5 million a year. They would end up in jails, emergency rooms, impacting local social-service departments and law enforcement.”

The board, at the motion of Commissioner Carol Peterson swiftly adopted a motion to oppose the move in no uncertain terms.

“We have a moral obligation to do this,” Chair David Gantt said. “We don’t need the state ripping away money we’ve properly managed and accumulated through good business practices. It’s horrifying to hear this. Every time we have a crisis, the first ones to get kicked off the bus are children, working people and the mentally ill.”

In other developments at the meeting:

• The latest attempt to finalize an agreement between Buncombe County and the city of Asheville on consolidating their 911 services was again delayed in a 4-1 vote, as most of the board balked at a provision that would see the county paying $2.5 million to the city if Buncombe backed out of the agreement.

“This is intended to provide more rapid communications between the different agencies — and we’ve already seen that,” Fire Marshal Mack Salley said.

But so far the city and county have been operating on a preliminary 2003 agreement. Because the city at the time was forgoing state dollars it could have received from being its own 911 provider — and because it would have to build a new facility if the county terminated the agreement in the future, city officials asked for the reimbursement provision. Also, if the city chooses to back out, it will take equipment the city paid for as part of the agreement.

That didn’t sit well with Vice Chair Bill Stanley, who thought it unfair.

“So wait, if the county backs out, we pay the city $2.5 million, and if they back out, they keep the equipment,” Stanley said. “Either way, we get nothing. That doesn’t seem right.”

Peterson shared Stanley’s concerns, and asked County Manager Wanda Greene to take the agreement back to City Manager Gary Jackson and improve the provision to carrying penalties for both parties if the agreement is terminated.

However, Commissioner Holly Jones, a former City Council member, said she could see the city’s point of view and thought the agreement didn’t need to be delayed any longer.

“I’m really excited we’re going to have a big city/county win, but that price tag is because the city’s forgone dollars they would have if they didn’t go into this agreement for the greater good of the community,” Jones said. “I don’t think the county would ever back out of this agreement, but if they for some reason did, they could never get that money back. It looks a little lopsided, but there’s a reason for it.”

Peterson replied by pointing out that the county had spent millions on building and equipping the new emergency facility, including the 911 center.

Greene said that so far the system is working well for all parties and there would be no reason to terminate it, but that she would speak to Jackson.

The board voted, at Peterson’s motion, to delay the matter for a month at most. Jones said she couldn’t support that.

— David Forbes, staff writer


Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

3 thoughts on “A problem of money: Commissioners face mental-health shortfall, delay 911 agreement

  1. LOKEL

    I think it is high time to consolidate the City and County services into one – including the Commissioners and the City Council.

    This way the rankling between the two could be set aside for the common good of the citizens of the metro area within Buncombe.

    Charlotte and Mecklenburg did this a few years back – not only did it stop the in-fitting, which often resulted in getting nothing accomplished, it resulted in better representation of the various rural and urban areas overall… since the new “Board” was comprised of numbered districts (like North, South, East and West) which elected their own reps to b e on the “Council”.

    I am not suggesting this apply to the schools – although it would probably increase State monies to the combined systems and eliminate redundancy in the non-teaching employees of the two current systems…

  2. evolved

    Good point Lokel. I hardly ever agree with your posts, but I agree about combining the city and county schools. I think we could do with only one administration. We would have a lot more teachers.

  3. John Smolkin

    Here we go. The county and city government have spent our tax money on things that they shouldn’t have. Like the arts and parks. Now, something they SHOULD fund, 911 emergency services, is put on hold because they over-spent on the things they shouldn’t have. We need to elect people to commissions and councils who understand what government should fund, and what it should not.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.