Train reaction

In 1880, the telegraph was the fastest means of communication, using long and short beeps to send messages hundreds of miles. The fastest way to travel across the country was by train. Today we've come full circle: We talk in tweets, and we dream of ways to use the "rapid transport" Google Fiber would bring to the city.

I began wondering why the train didn't come to Asheville while living on the Warren Wilson College campus at the start of this decade. And when my son was born in 2005, I made a commitment that by the time my kids were old enough to drive, they wouldn't need a car to get in and out of Asheville.

On a recent excursion on the Amtrak Crescent line, we discovered the joys of scooting across the landscape without the distractions of the road. Unlike planes, the train affords riders considerable freedom, allowing people to interact while sitting, standing or even walking. There are no billboards and no traffic, and passengers can see both the interior of cities and the wild lands that lie beyond our car-centric communities.

Beyond its rich cultural appeal, train travel is energy-efficient, convenient for families and relaxing. And with electricity at every seat and onboard WI-FI not too far off, trains have become my preferred means of travel for trips taking more than two hours. Within the next decade, I envision being able to catch the train from our home in Black Mountain as part of the proposed Asheville-to-Salisbury line (see map at

To see how much support could be drummed up quickly, I set up a Facebook group I call "The People for Rail to Asheville." In just five days, it grew to include more than 500 people from across the region and beyond.

Here's what a few of them had to say.

"Passenger trains fit in perfectly with the city of Asheville's Green Initiatives Project," noted Mary-Allison Wright Lind. "More public transportation will only help with pollution control and long-term costs of maintaining and widening existing roads."

Paul Benson, meanwhile, considered the broader economic picture. "It is clear that the economic future of Asheville and Western North Carolina will be dependent on [attracting] new investment and the type of new citizens that may live/visit/retire anywhere but choose a place because of the natural and cultural amenities it offers. Passenger-rail service is one of these amenities. In addition to the obvious advantages of having another transportation alternative … passenger-rail service would have a multiplier effect on local economies by stimulating investment and redevelopment in the typically blighted railroad corridors within these communities. The "spin-off" economic benefits … are probably the strongest justification for the extension."

Phil Atwood wrote: "As we continue down the road of using more and more imported oil … the cost of gasoline will continue to increase. … Rail travel will become one of the primary alternatives to the automobile. Those tourist communities that are ready for rail travel are the ones that will not only survive, but grow and prosper. We need to be a leader as one of those communities."

And Jill Boniske recalled: "When I was a child, you could get on a train in Biltmore in the evening, have a nice dinner in the dining car, sleep comfortably and wake somewhere around D.C. to breakfast and then be in NYC just in time to shop. That was wonderful! Civilized. No craziness in the airports. No cramped seating. No driving in and out of the city when you arrive. Those were the good old days, and we should bring them back."

Buncombe County planner James Coman, who's served on committees to determine a site for the multimodal transit center proposed by the DOT, said: "It is my understanding that the most costly hurdle to overcome is the physical condition of the track east of Asheville. It is sufficient for freight but is considerably below the quality mandated for passenger service."

The Swannanoa grade between Black Mountain and Old Fort is a challenging landscape, making this an expensive but not impossible project. The signals and tracks must be upgraded, and there will need to be negotiations with Norfolk Southern. We need funding to bring the train up the mountain.

"As recently as the early 1980s," noted Coman, "steam-powered tourist trains regularly made trips during the fall color season and were always popular. Much earlier in life, I traveled the train to Old Fort on numerous occasions; the Swannanoa grade is particularly scenic, with seven tunnels and stunning views."

What's being done?

In February, I attended a meeting of the Western North Carolina Passenger Rail Corridor Committee, led by Asheville resident Judy Ray. It became clear that support and active participation by both Asheville and Buncombe County are essential. And on March 23, the Asheville City Council unanimously adopted a resolution reconfirming support for the WNC Rail Initiative. On April 7, corridor committee members will make a presentation to the General Assembly's Standing Committee on Comprehensive Rail Service Plan about the importance for North Carolina of reopening the Asheville line.

In an e-mail exchange with Asheville Mayor Terry Bellamy, she wrote: "I am very supportive of passenger rail returning to our region. In 2008 and 2009, I served on the [N.C. General Assemblly's] 21st Century Transportation Committee, which looked closely at passenger-rail services currently being provided in North Carolina and the future of [such] services. During that time, it was disclosed that Asheville continues to be the No. 1 requested destination location without service." And officials to the west of us, she noted, would like to have rail service between Asheville and Cherokee.

"I believe that passenger-rail service will increase tourism and economic-development opportunities for our city and region," Bellamy continued, adding that it "will support Asheville City Council's goal of having a truly multimodal transportation system."

The Western North Carolina Railroad first reached Asheville on Oct. 3, 1880: 130 years later, it's time to bring that train back to town!

[Black Mountain resident Brett McCall is a project manager for DelKote's Spray Foam Insulation Division and a self-appointed virtual town crier.
Beyond its rich cultural appeal, train travel is energy-efficient, convenient for families and relaxing.]

About Webmaster
Mountain Xpress Webmaster Follow me @MXWebTeam

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

10 thoughts on “Train reaction

  1. nuvue

    I would love to see upgraded train travel to this area. It would have to be almost as efficient as car travel time wise, in order to compete. I just tried to get my elderly mom from Atlanta to Raleigh and it would have left her overnight waiting for a connection in Salisbury or someplace….. Not good. Anyhow, trains will have to become a better method. I just befriended a scottish guy here and he was bemoaning the poor train service and couldn’t believe the backwards thinking of America’s rail service compared to every other developed country.

  2. Ben Frederock

    Wow in this article is enough knowledge about the train situation here in Western NC to know it will happen. Surely still a good bit of work to encourage planning council and other support. But if any growing town can make a good thing happen, it is Asheville. Bravo! Looking forward to it.

  3. hauntedheadnc

    It would help if rail service to Asheville would consist of more than just a spur down to Salisbury. It’s just wishful thinking, but if rail service ran from Salisbury on through Asheville to Knoxville, Nashville, Memphis and onward, we’d be so much better off. It’s better to be on a street that goes somewhere rather than a dead-end, in other words.

  4. UNaffiliated Voter

    Lets just make sure the government is NOT involved…

  5. travelah

    Do you really think Asheville and the area can generate enough interest to support rail service?

  6. kdog77

    I have had several rounds of correspondence with Rep. Ray Rapp (D-Madison), who chairs the General Assembly’s Standing Committee on Comprehensive Rail Service Plan. I agree that eventually east-west service from Asheville is important, it is more important right now to connect to the existing AMTRAK service in the Piedmont (most likely Salisbury). To our west, the nearest AMTRAK service is in Memphis. We need to push our elected representatives in Raleigh and Washington on this issue as vital to economic growth and environmental protection. Let’s spend money on upgrading rail service, instead of more and more asphalt.

  7. BigAl

    Having moved from Durham, where I still have family, I would love the opportunity to train back to visit, also for day-trips to the State Fair, Festival for the Eno and a few other thiongs that RDU has that are not in WNC, especially around Christmas. I loathe the 3+1/2 hour car trip and if the rail isn’t high-speed, at least I can nap on the way.

  8. ashkat

    I’m going to DC during spring break and discovered that if you qualify for one of their 15% discount programs, AMTRAK costs less than either air or driving alone. Driving is an hour or two shorter only if you can do it without stopping. Added benefits: I can sleep in a wide, comfortable seat on the train and arrive in md, dc, or va at a convenient stop with subway connections.

  9. wendy

    so what can I do to help make train service in asheville a reality?

  10. Betty Cloer Wallace

    “Do you really think Asheville and the area can generate enough interest to support rail service?”


Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.