Sheep without a shepherd

If a visitor to Asheville asked a passerby, “Take me to your leader,” the visitor would probably be met with only a blank stare.

Like a person born beautiful or handsome, Asheville sometimes seems to rely on its natural endowments while suffering from a shortage of character and vision. Only a clearly visible and highly respected leader can exercise the kind of moral persuasion that calls forth a community’s potential goodness. Where is Asheville’s leader?

Ordinarily one expects such leadership to arise from the journalistic Fourth Estate (the press), from religious institutions, or from visionary individuals in government or the business community. According to local legend, Asheville was formerly run by a triumvirate: the newspaper editor, the sheriff and the city manager. Since that time, however, civil libertarians and litigious activists have deposed the “bosses” nationwide. But in Asheville, at least, that healthy change has created a continuing leadership vacuum.

In recent years, exemplary individuals across North Carolina have successfully promoted such causes as beautification, racial reconciliation, equitable employment and housing, and good stewardship of land and resources. All these programs have created notable civic pride and a consensus impulse to improve every citizen’s quality of life. Some familiar examples are four-term Charlotte Mayor John Belk; civil rights leaders such as former Durham Mayor Wense Grabarek and the Rev. Vernon Tyson in racially torn Oxford, N.C.; writer John Ehle (who urges social justice and ethnic liberation through his works); and Sam Ragan, the Sandhills newspaperman and poet who reported the good news of human goodness and gently promoted “doing the right thing.” But who is Asheville’s leader?

Throughout history, when government, church, press and business have failed to lead or to produce a leader, it has fallen to unlikely citizens to claim that mantle. Whether in village, city or nation, leadership arises from the human spirit. Consider these anonymous people who stepped up to become heroic leaders: Mohandas Gandhi, an émigré lawyer; Nelson Mandela, the incarcerated icon of South Africa; playwright Václav Havel, who led the democratization of Czechoslovakia and the Czech Republic; and Lech Walesa of Gdansk, a shipyard worker who freed Poland from its Communist overlords. Apparently, none of these pioneers set out to change the existing political system or to challenge the established power structure, but all of them accepted the ordination of circumstance.

What do these foreign figures have to do with Asheville, N.C.? As with all inspirational models, there must be sufficient distance to allow for idealization and enough proximity for identification. These four from afar can serve as effective guides for Asheville by virtue of their shared struggle to humanize communities and individuals. Who could fail to be thrilled by Mandela’s call for resolving conflict through truth and reconciliation?

Conflict, oppression, violence, and economic and spiritual impoverishment are not “foreign affairs.” At the local level, they translate into things like the disparity between hut and castle, the encroachment of heedless development on the gift of open space, the widening gap between poverty and privilege, the escalation of drug trafficking and overt criminality, and pervasive attitudes of hopelessness, demoralization and cynicism. Who in Asheville will combine sufficient tenderness and toughness to lead us toward a brighter and more realistic future?

Surely most of us know or know about women and men in our community who are working faithfully for equal opportunity and justice in their respective islands of business, government, the judiciary, the law, health care, education and the church; but isolation dilutes their collective impact. Who is there in Asheville who’ll step forward and connect the dots?

Leaders who help foster the wholeness of community must always guard against personal ambition in order to promote public altruism. A humanizing leader must have the courage to say “No” to grandiosity and the generosity to broadcast a heartfelt “Yes” to healthy community.

Speaking at a tribute dinner, one of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s students observed, “Mr. Emerson always led us to ourselves rather than to himself.”

The Emerson mantle is rich, but assuming it can be a daunting prospect. Who in Asheville will wear that mantle?

[Dr. Robert Phillips, a former professor of clinical psychiatry at Duke University and assistant professor at UNC-Chapel Hill, lives in Asheville with his wife, Susan Sihler.]

About Webmaster
Mountain Xpress Webmaster Follow me @MXWebTeam

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

17 thoughts on “Sheep without a shepherd

  1. Orbit DVD

    Ok, you guys talked me into it. I will lead the city of Asheville.


  2. We don’t need one leader – no one individual has all the answers.

    We need a vision as an active community on how to grow with forethought and purpose. Then and only then can the leaders within the community step forward and together work within the community’s needs and concerns. That is what the ideal city council would do – but like all democratic elections – we find many flaws to our voting process. Especially when few citizens vote…

    If people were really interested in Asheville’s development and growth, including fair living wages, a stronger employment economy, degentrification, and affordable housing (to name a very few of the many incredibly important issues facing our community), one would hope people would come out to the polls.

    However an active community doesn’t stop at voting, there must be constant communication and dialog to create positive momentous action.

    A major problem with Asheville is there are two mind sets and only one of them is organized. We find the affluent investor examining and exploiting the profits of urban sprawl, real estate hikes, and mountain top removal – vs – the people who live here who want to take advantage of the healthy mountain environment and caring community Asheville has to offer.

    I guess Ashevillian’s need to really ask themselves what they want out of Asheville, both now and in ten years. Then based on that response the citizens need to focus and organize their energy and attention.

    It takes a community to run a city.
    It takes visionary leaders to blaze the way into making ideas become reality.

  3. travelah

    Hopefully you will bring free beer Thursdays and a 35 hour work week along with all of August dedicated to a personal sabatical for every worker. Only then can the workers of Asheville truly experience the good life that the fauxprogs are living and promising to everybody else. Will you also PLEASE get rid of paper plates and napkins so we can save a few southern pine trees and really show we are green? Maybe you could get Asheville to provide wooden beer mugs for every worker to use on Thursdays and even make us use Chinese Melmac sold out of a shop on Lexington Ave. I think you can do great things for Asheville and make us proud …

    … seriously, the opening post contans the musings of idiocy and I thought mine would match his. It reminds me of that devious Democrat running for President who in spouting her old SDS mindset wrote a whole book stating it takes a village to raise a child. No knuckleheaded leftist lady, it takes parents! Same mindset with the OP … we don’t need a visionary to set up shop in Asheville. Asheville simply needs the sane and reasonably minded middle to take back what the fauxprogs have siezed from them.

  4. Orbit DVD

    “ooh ooh! Please lead me! I need to be lead? ooh ooh ooh! Asheville needs another Ghandi!”

    You don’t get the power. I got here first.


  5. Hopefully

    Thats it? Thats the best you can do? One personal attack on JBo followed with a snide aside about Clinton? The world needs another Ghandi…

  6. mockeyjew

    What are you so mad about traverler? You seem like a real know itall. you should be more respectfull of people runnig for president they are your betters. Hey ralph dont you work down at the chicken place? I will say hello next time I am there. My real name is frank

  7. Hopefully

    I think I saw Ralph at a restaurant also, but I don’t think he was working there. But he was sure eating chicken.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.