Street Preacher Ruckus

It’s become an annual ritual: Street preachers descend on Asheville for Bele Chere, and Ashevilleans come out to confront them — or simply watch the chaos. This year was no exception.

Photo by Jerry Nelson

The action
It’s Friday, July 23, and an audience rings Pritchard park, where one preacher is launching into the middle of a sermon, pacing, stomping and shouting.

“You haven’t obeyed your parents,” he says into a megaphone. “You have to believe…”

“Sit down, you’ve had your chance, let someone else talk!” one man shouts from the crowd.

Someone asks the preacher something about the meaning of God being love, and he waves it off. “I’m talking right now, I’ll take questions later.”

“This guy sucks!” one woman shouts, clearly not satisified with the free entertainment.

After a few further barbs are thrown back and forth, the audience begins asking the preacher what church he’s from and where he prays. Seemingly flustered, he pauses for a moment and says, “I pray in my closet.” The preacher’s invoking Matthew 6:5-6 which, ironically enough, reads: “And when you pray, you must not be like the hypocrites. For they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and at the street corners, that they may be seen by others. Truly, I say to you, they have received their reward. But when you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret.”

But he’s walked into the trap, and on cue, scattered shouts of “come out of the closet!” from the crowd turn into a chanting chorus.

As the crowd gets worked up, two men with open Bud Lights in cozies wind their way through the crowd, searching for a seat. They’re spectators, and their reason for coming out here is simple.

“It’s fucking hilarious,” one says to the other, motioning to the preacher and the hecklers.

Similar scenes occur all over the weekend as street preachers (often from outside the area) along with their opponents (usually locals), square off in displays of spectacle, shouting and (every once in awhile) actual debate.

With its ampitheatre-like layout, Pritchard Park is a popular venue for preachers in action. This exchange also took place on Friday.

Many of the street preachers are of the fundamentalist variety, as evidenced by the signs and brimstone rhetoric. Hell is frequently invoked, as is judgement and Jesus’ imminent return:

Photo by Michael Muller

Preaching on Saturday
But despite their ubiquity at Bele Chere, both preachers and protestors are often reluctant to talk to the press. But Keith Higgins, from Atlanta, Ga., spoke to Xpress: On Saturday morning, he leans on a large wooden cross at the corner of Haywood and College , passing out information about his ministry, which he dubs Saved From What. Higgins says he doesn’t always want to be associated with some of the other preachers, whose aggressive tactics he believes to be inappropriate.

“I just talk the Gospel with passing crowds,” he says. “We get a mixed reception. Some people are receptive and some just don’t want to hear it. We don’t try and force them, we just let them go by.”

But why Bele Chere? “The number of people,” he says. “Really, we travel all over. We just got back from the major league baseball All-Star game in Los Angeles. We go to the Super Bowl. Anywhere where there’s lots of people. When there’s something big like this and it’s only three hours away, it’s a no-brainer.”

Just about 10 feet from Higgins, Scott Smith, a schoolteacher from Georgia, warms up.

“This nation is in a famine, not a food famine, but a famine for the word of God,” Smith says as he looks around — most of the milling crowds continue on their way. “They don’t even know the Ten Commandments. They think they’re the ten suggestions. … Now some of you may say ‘I don’t believe Jesus is the lord.’ It doesn’t matter what we believe. If you don’t believe in gravity and you jump off that building, does it mean gravity doesn’t exist? No.”

Smith receives little acknowledgement. He closes his Bible for a moment and asks them, under the unrelenting sun of the hottest festival in memory, if they’re “walking in darkness.”

While the preachers do tend to draw their opponents out in force, it’s not uncommon to hear a positive shout in the midst of the detractors, especially at lines like “You need a savior!” (a common phrase, it seems, in the repertoire of any street preacher).

Over by the Vance monument, the preachers can be a more belligerent variety. Signs proclaim the final resting place of “drunkards and fornicators” (take a wild guess) or, well, this viewpoint:

Photo by Michael Muller

That’s a particular point of conflict in Asheville, with its sizable LGBT population, and the damnation of homosexuals expressed by the preachers is a frequent target of the detractors’ criticism (including, it should be said, from other Christians who find it intolerant).

Local Jeremy Carter decides he’s had enough and heads over to local bookstore Malaprop’s, where he buys a rainbow flag to express his own particular view. He returns to Vance and brandishes it through the spiels of four preachers. His display does not go unnoticed.

Photo by Michael Muller

“The homosexuals have stolen the rainbow from scripture, and they’ve twisted what the Bible says. The rainbow is a symbol of god’s judgement,” says Tony Denham, from Goldsboro as he stands on a platform and motions to Carter. “It’s very ironic; this man is holding a symbol that will be the death of him. Flee! Flee your homosexuality! Flee your bondage!”

Carter, who receives cheers and thanks from some passerby, explains his own move as simply taking a stand against a hateful ideology: “I grew up in a fundamentalist Christian household,” he tells Xpress. “There are probably people walking around right now, struggling with their sexuality. I don’t want them to just hear this garbage,” he says, indicating Denham.

He is sooned joined by Batwoman (Ashevillean Hillary Frye, spreading the word about the Fanaticon convention).

Photo by Michael Muller

Legally, the preachers — and their detractors — are on fairly firm First Amendment grounds, which have wide protections for speech in public spaces (even allowing for personal amplification equipment) as long as the participants don’t engage in physical violence or directly provoke others to it. It’s not uncommon to see police observing the proceedings at the three major areas — Pritchard Park, the intersection of Haywood and College and the Vance Monument — where the vast majority of the preacher confrontations takes place each Bele Chere.

However, there’s plenty of ways to make one’s point or vie for verbal space. Also at Vance, a busker painted all in silver sets up in front of a street preacher bellowing about sin (“sinners die and they go to hell!”). Her rapid drumming drowns him out — and proves a savvy business move at the same time: Onlookers not only cheer her wildly but throw one, five and even 10-dollar bills her way to keep the noise going.

Photo by David Forbes. My apologies for the poor quality, caught this scene on my phone.

In addition to the preachers, there’s also Cameron Heatherly, who proclaims allegiance to his own particular sect, the Church of Reptology and its deity The… well, best to let the sign do the talking.

Photo by Michael Muller

“Velociraptors are misunderstood: They were actually intelligent and relatively nonviolent,” Heatherly told Xpress. “They’re preaching evil over there. We’re for understanding.”

So, to review, street preachers bearing signs about hellfire and damnation were countered by, among many others, a drumming street performer, a local citizen brandishing a rainbow flag, Batwoman and followers of the Great Velociraptor.

Only in Asheville.

Of course, in a city of subcultures, many of whom they condemn, the street preachers also form their own — however temporary — with their internal arguments and different points of view (remember Higgins’ objections to some of the others’ tactics), along with a need to stick together. There even seems to be aesthetic trends: Signs bearing long lists of sins were a familiar sight last year, but this year seemed to have been mostly replaced by hellfire and judgment motifs.

Late Saturday afternoon, a group of preachers could be seen relaxing on Haywood. Marcus Pittman, from Virginia Beach, Va., had come to Bele Chere to preach for his third year in a row. He spoke to Xpress about what he sees as a holy mission to save souls from hell.

“We’re getting the same response we normally get: Some people really like it, some people hate it,” Pittman said. “We don’t have any expectation when we come out here to preach that people will love it.”

He mentioned the early Christian figure Stephen getting stoned to death, along with the similar demises of many of the apostles, “we know the Gospel is offensive.”

Why does he think Asheville crowds often directly confront street preachers?

“In Asheville, it’s saying that Jesus Christ is the way, the truth: I think that’s very offensive in Asheville. There’s a lot of post-modern thought, universalism, a coexistence mentality,” he said, adding that “some preachers’ approach is to specifically and aggressively be offensive. Some of what we preach is offensive by the nature of its exclusivity, but I have no desire to use derogatory slurs or offensive words for their own sake.”

That evening, Pittman himself was in front of Vance monument, thumbing through his Bible and readying himself before launching into his own sermon.

“Neither fornicators or idolators or adulterers or the effeminate or abusers of themselves or mankind or revelers or extortioners shall inherit the kingdom of God,” he says, quoting from Corinthians. “Understand, Asheville, that you’ve all broken God’s law, and the only just thing for God to do with you is to throw you in hell if Christ did not come.”

“Bullshit, he’s a fascist!” a man from the crowd shouted, pointing at Pittman.

Photo by Margaret Williams

“Explain yourself,” Pittman replies, before leaning closer and hearing the man’s objection. “It’s a good point, a loving God won’t throw people into hell. But will a just God throw people into hell? God is loving, but he is also just. He must punish those who rebel.”

Not everyone enjoys the ruckus. Canadian visitor “Donny J,” observing Pittman, didn’t think it should be allowed at all. He sees the preachers’ activities as hate speech that should be banned by law.

“This is a hate crime where I’m from: You can’t stand on a street corner telling gay people they’re going to burn in hell just like you can’t stand on the street and say black people are any less than white people,” Donny J says. “Seeing that this is somehow tucked under First Amendment rights is absolutely bogus. There’s a clear distinction between preaching absolute, pure hate and free speech. It’s completely distracting, the whole festival’s been about this. Every street you go on, there’s another preacher shouting through a megaphone and people shouting back. This is fascism, legalized fascism.”

Ashevillean Torva Logan, also observing, isn’t too fond of the annual confrontations.

“People didn’t come here to hear this, they’re here by the city’s grace, so basically the city has sanctioned a bunch of Christians to stand around and tell us we’re going to hell,” she told Xpress. “I don’t understand how this is helping the city at all.”

But whether people came for it or not, there it is, every year, as much of a fixture as funnel cake and beer. Ashevilleans, living in one of the more liberal cities in the Southeast, get a rare opportunity to directly confront some of the more hardline prosyletizers who condemn many of their own lifestyles.

Photo by Jonathan Welch

Nothing’s quite as invigorating as a good enemy, after all, and the Bele Chere provides an opportunity for locals to cut loose against their ideological opponents in relative safety, with a built-in audience nearby.

Come to think of it, that’s exactly what the preachers get too.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

22 thoughts on “Street Preacher Ruckus

  1. Jason Ross Martin

    Having been delighted to be employed by the lovely Susan, owner of The Open Door Boutique as well as Street Fair, for my fourth time this Bele Chere, I was stricken by the horrible job done by our local government in protecting the rights of merchants.

    I witnesses firsthand a few distinct lulls in sales at our location at the intersection of College and Haywood, a prime location which Susan has garnered after 29 years in a row at Bele Chere. Lulls which came at the same time that the Street Preachers were yelling at passersby. So loudly did one “preacher” keep saying the word ‘whoremonger’ I could see our potential customers grimace and walk on, if not avoid our booth altogether because of the ridiculousness of the onslaught of “messages.”

    I approached Asheville Police to ask them about our rights. The fact was, Susan had spent a lot of money, and was employing at least 4 people that weekend, to have her booth for the 29th consecutive year. The fact the her operation was compromised, even for a moment, to the whims of a person who had paid nothing to inflict their peculiar brand of englightnment, not just once but for periods of 10 consecutive hours or more…it was ridiculous.

    But the police said the Street Preachers had hired a lawyer and quote ‘Our hands are tied’ in terms of asking them to leave or pipe down a bit. One group had a P.A. and microphone. Ironically, amplification is NEVER allowed by street buskers during regular days in our fair city. But these individuals are allowed to broadcast their rhetoric into the booths of those paying for space and employing locals, like me, who would have been out of work for those days because my other job was CLOSED DUE TO THE MASSIVE FOOT TRAFFIC who are the prime customers for Susan and her shops!?!@>!@!@

    I implore the government of Asheville to ban amplification by Street Preachers at Bele Chere. And to protect the sanctity and volume level forced upon PAYING participants in the festival like Susan and her booth for Street Fair and The Open Door.

    Give the Street Preachers a stage if you want, but enforce a schedule and a proximity to their message–especially if they are allowed a PA!

    • sws

      Sorry, didn’t realize the amazing festival is no longer running…. maybe it can reinvent itself without shutting down businesses and streets? Music festivals can be really amazing– Hope this one can come back.
      The City of West Hollywood, during gay pride festival, relegates the religious hate to one corner and they are surrounded by police, which keeps them in line and pretty tame- Most people don’t even know they are there.
      Its amazing to me how these fake “religious” cults think HATE is an effective tool that would change anyone? Can you imagine Jesus saying and doing the garbage those people do? NO.

  2. Michael Muller

    Fun post — you really captured the dynamics of it all. Great job, Scooter!

  3. LOKEL

    These “preachers” are covered by the First Amendment, and as the article clearly states, they are doing nothing illegal.

    I do not support their actions.

    Maybe some folks could get those “horns in a can” that boaters have and just blast away while they are screaming about jesus.

  4. Ken Hanke

    You have to stay silent though.

    With all the Leviticus biz, I was envisioning people dressed up as shellfish engaging in indecent acts.

  5. Ignorance shouts loudest; Better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.

    I agree that amplification should be banned. But the “preachers” have every right to shout their ignorance and prejudice. They do not realize that they are doing more harm to the message of Jesus than they are doing any good.

    Ignore them; they are not worthy of attention. Do not argue with them, reason is excluded from emotional ignorance. Just roll your eyes and keep moving.

  6. Josh Benson

    I guess it’s fun for some, but I don’t really see the point in arguing with these folks. The most damaging thing you could possibly do to them is pretend they aren’t there at all. By arguing with them you only reinforce their victim mentality and give them stories of persecution that make them look like holy martyrs to their cohorts. Their authoritarian mindset will never allow them to actually consider the flaws of their message, regardless of how many “gotchas” they are publicly embarrassed with. It’s just as fun for them to argue and bicker with people because at least they’ve got your attention. The whole point of their presence is to provoke a reaction by being offensive and loud, to stoke their own egos.

    I say we set up a “Free Speech Zone” for them down under the bridge on Riverside and let them shout to their hearts content to anyone who cares to go all the way down there and listen. Above all I think people should stop acknowledging them, negatively or positively, because either way it just encourages more of their hateful, ignorant diatribes. I recognize, however sadly, that this is a futile request.

  7. Barry Summers

    Don’t worry guys. Next year I have a plan…

    Does it involve coprophagia?

  8. djmrthebest

    last year as i was walking around hell share for my yearly mandated 20 minutes i noticed that the “preachers” had huge posters of aborted fetuses and car crash victims supposedly being used to oppose abortion and drunk driving. is that what i would want my 8 year old kid looking up and seeing while at a “festival”? fuck no. so i approached a police officer and said “can you at least make them put those posters away? that is just sick and offensive.” the officer said he would see what he could do. i never heard the result. were there any posters like that this year? if so, dont worry guys, next year i have a plan

  9. boatrocker

    Hmmm good point raised about asking “why are street preachers allowed PAs and speakers within Bele Chere limits yet buskers aren’t”.

    Maybe buskers should hire lawyers too like the street preachers do. Could any local gov types elaborate on why one group is allowed public address systems within Bele Chere limits yet not another? Don’t worry, I’m not expecting a clear answer to this question either, I’m just putting it out there.

    In seeing different reactions here (ignore them, shout them down, try to talk sense), whether it’s a street preacher or a similar thread in the forums about posters who seem to be above moderation, just remember that these people are only bullies. Yep, the same ones from school days, only all grown up with bank accounts and voting rights.

    Whatever blowhards who shout down posters on forums for being bound for hell are no different than the blowhards on the street during Bele Chere- the simple fact is neither the City of Asheville nor other posters (here) will call them down for being afraid of retribution. The ones that do suffer the “slings and arrows” for it.

    Nope, don’t color me a weenie liberal. They’ve had the country handed to them on a platter since winning both houses as well as the White House. Don’t color me a neo-con either. I’m just pointing out that the 1st Amendment right that allows folks to spew shouldn’t be curtailed, but readers and festival goers should recognize (sadly legal) hate speech when they see it.

  10. Torva

    Don’t worry guys. Next year I have a plan…

    This is good news – I want to know more too…

    Next year I have some things up my sleeve as well.

  11. Devin

    A plan? Seriously? How childish is this going to get? I read a balanced article, then some guys are here talking about a plan to screw with the street preachers?

    So much for tolerance eh? Coexist?

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.