Co-op means cooperating

In response to the recent letters about consumer cooperatives: The cooperative movement has experienced a lot of pressure from the capitalist system. Whenever the market for a commodity that a cooperative is providing becomes large enough, large corporations move in to capture a significant portion of that market. People are not informed enough about the reasons for creating and sustaining a cooperative economic system, and a majority yield to the convenience and perceived lower prices provided by capitalistic corporations. Many cooperatives have gone under as a result.

Cooperatives have responded by becoming more and more like the corporations that are capturing their markets. Instead of expanding education and outreach to maintain a dedicated ownership core and emphasizing their democratic basis and community spirit, cooperatives have tended to reduce spending in “nonproductive” areas that do not directly increase profitability—thus reducing direct owner-involvement in “operational” decisions. In other words, decisions that directly affect owners’ shopping experiences in their own store are decisions over which they have the least control. For instance, while the owners of a food co-op could vote to have a salad bar, this will not necessarily lead to the store’s having a salad bar. Such a decision is considered operational, and the co-op board might not create a policy related to the creation of a salad bar, nor direct the store’s general manager to abide by the ownership’s decision.

The capitalistic economic model is destroying the Earth’s ecosystems. We need an economic model with a bottom line that includes the health of the people, our communities and our planet. Everyone reading this can help bolster and create an economic model where the bottom line is our community. We can do this by participating in alternative institutions and encouraging them to work toward a more participatory governance model that meets the needs of the community. Rather than continuing to support and patronize capitalistic corporate entities, if more and more people—like you—become owners of and involved in cooperative institutions like the French Broad Food Co-op, the Haywood Road Market and the Hendersonville Community Co-op, these institutions will become more responsive to our participation. Otherwise, we may lose the chance that they represent to move toward an economic system that puts people before profit.

If you are an owner of the French Broad Food Co-op, now is a crucial time to become involved. A committee has been formed to look at the bylaws and make them clearer and more understandable. Bylaws can help our board to be more responsive to ownership decisions if they make clear the role of the ownership within the decision-making process. Many perspectives need to be represented in this process. Our bylaws need to reflect desires and input from all segments of the co-op community. Various levels of involvement will be available. I encourage you to participate. For more info contact me at, or call me at 277-0758.

— Cicada Brokaw

About Webmaster
Mountain Xpress Webmaster Follow me @MXWebTeam

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

One thought on “Co-op means cooperating

  1. William P Miller

    Cicada, this is America. We have competition, free enterprise,and capitalism. We have a lot of opportunity, freedom, and wealth, as a result.. Our way of doing things is the reason why we have such a wonderful supply of goods at competitive prices. The French Broad Co-op’s experiment in socialism has proven to be a failure. Greenlife and Earthfare have people friendly prices….and good attitudes. Your customers went there. Not only to save money, but because of the attitude of many of the clerks at FBC. The yankee custom of not saying “thank you”,and self-centeredness, at the checkout is a turn off to those of us who are local and are used to friendly service. Hence, a management change at FBC to try to make it more competitive. I occasionally go,but not often. Why? Even though the prices are better now, the smugness of some of the workers is still there. I do not like doing business at a place where the help act like they are doing you a favor.

    And, Earthfare and Greenlife are not large corporations. What people need is the competition we now have. Your”educating” them (indocrinating is a better word) to think like a socialist,is flat out wrong. God bless America, our freedoms, and our capitalist system. This is the best place on earth to live because of our traditions.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.