Misperceptions all around

Driving on I-240 recently, I passed a tan Explorer sitting on the left shoulder of the road, headlights flashing and blue lights inside. In front of this vehicle was a motorcycle, with a helmeted man standing there. As I passed, I noticed in the rearview window that the Explorer was pulling back on to the interstate, so I stayed in the right-hand lane and the Explorer passed me on the left, with all lights now off. I pulled in behind him, going almost 60, but thought I would lose him before getting the license plate numbers. However, he got stuck behind a tanker truck and I did manage to catch up to him [and get] the number. I [then] passed him on the right and looked at him. He was a white man who did not appear to be wearing a police uniform.

It appeared to me that this was an undercover cop in an unmarked vehicle giving a traffic citation to the guy on the motorcycle. I am of the opinion that having unmarked police cars stopping traffic for citations greatly increases the danger to women in our city, since we will not know the difference between a legitimate cop and a pretend cop with lights inside his vehicle. I [also think] that having officers deliver traffic citations while out of uniform increases the danger to women traveling in the region.

If this was a legitimate police officer doing a legitimate traffic stop, he needs to stop being a hypocrite and start respecting traffic laws himself. If this is someone driving around impersonating police officers, he needs to be in jail.

At a recent forum at UNCA, Sheriff Duncan [indicated he] thinks the population is suffering from misperceptions of his deputies. He also admitted that the recent arrest over a flag display was unlawful—but not that Deputy Scarborough went into the Kuhn’s home without probable cause or a search warrant or their permission. This was, in my eyes, a home invasion. I find it frightening that this was done without any repercussions to the deputy. I think it is Sheriff Duncan who is suffering from misperceptions.

I also witnessed an incident at Bele Chere and wrote a letter to Chief Hogan two months ago, who now says he has finished the investigation [but] has yet to set up a meeting with me and other witnesses. He did inform me at the UNCA forum that I did not see what I thought I saw.

The sheriff and the chief think the general public is suffering from misperceptions, and internal investigations seem to lead nowhere. If what I saw was an undercover police officer, I would like the city to stop using them for traffic stops and have the officer cited for speeding on I-240. If this was not a legitimate police officer, then that vehicle needs to be tracked down and this situation investigated.

— Susan Oehler

Chief Hogan responds: This is not an Asheville Police vehicle, and I do not know what agency has this vehicle in their fleet. You have a number of state agencies that do not wear uniforms but they are empowered to enforce all state laws. The State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) and Alcohol Law Enforcement (ALE) are two examples of such law enforcement agencies. Local law enforcement also has officers in plain-clothes assignments. It comes down to a judgment call by the non-uniformed officer on whether to stop or not. Should an officer allow someone who is drunk and a danger to other motorist[s] continue to drive, or should they attempt to make a stop?

I advise citizens who question whether a person attempting to stop them is a legitimate officer to drive to a busy location so they will not be isolated during the stop. They can call the local law enforcement agency if they have a cell phone to obtain assistance and ensure the unmarked vehicle is a legitimate police vehicle. 

Ms. Oehler has been invited to meet with me and others involved in her complaint about an officer’s conduct at Bele Chere … . My door is open for her to discuss her complaint with me and staff.


Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

2 thoughts on “Misperceptions all around

  1. lokel

    Chief Hogan says “I advise citizens who question whether a person attempting to stop them is a legitimate officer to drive to a busy location so they will not be isolated during the stop.”

    I did just that a few years back and pulled off the interstate to a well lit gas station and was beaten by the Asheville police who stopped me.

    I ended up having brain surgery a few months later to remove a blood clot caused by the blow to the head I received while in plain view of the patrons of the gas station.

    To Chief Hogan, I say, BS.

  2. travelah

    The chief is out of touch with the community. Refusing to stop for a rogue Asheville police officer is likely to result in abuse. If the Asheville police can beat citizens on a street in the daylight and taser citizens walking to feed a neighbors dog, something is terribly wrong not with the public but with a Neanderthall police department in the city of Asheville.
    I think it is time for the city council and Mayor to take control of the police department and replace it’s management if necessary. The people of Asheville and the surrounding communities as they are affected as well need to be served by their police force rather than dominated by them.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.