The Reader

Movie Information

The Story: A complex story of the impact that a youthful affair with an enigmatic older woman has on a man's entire life -- not so much because of the affair itself, but because of what he later learns about the past of the woman and his reaction to that discovery. The Lowdown: Brilliant and troubling, Stephen Daldry's The Reader is an uncompromisingly adult film that stays with you long after the movie is over.
Genre: Drama
Director: Stephen Daldry (The Hours)
Starring: Kate Winslet, Ralph Fiennes, David Kross, Bruno Ganz, Lena Olin
Rated: R

Admirers of the last collaboration between director Stephen Daldry and writer David Hare, The Hours (2002), should find much to please them in The Reader. Like their previous film, The Reader is heavy stuff. It has a nonlinear structure. And it’s haunting and deeply disturbing—perhaps even more so than The Hours. It is, in any case, clear why this material would appeal to the makers of The Hours. What is less clear is how much it will appeal to that film’s audience. The underpinnings of The Hours were very much in the “women’s picture” mode. The Hours could be—in many ways was—taken as an art-house soap opera. The Reader comes from a darker place altogether.

Stripped of its structural devices, the story follows the brief affair in 1958 between a 15-year-old German boy, Michael Berg (David Kross), and a 30-ish woman, Hanna Schmitz (Kate Winslet). That such a relationship is wrong isn’t actually addressed. It’s merely presented as something that happened, which will bother some viewers, but this isn’t the point of the story. When Hanna is nice to the boy one day—after finding him coming down with scarlet fever in the entryway to her building—Michael becomes interested in her. After he gets well, he goes to see her, ostensibly to thank her, but something more develops. It’s immediately clear what Michael gets out of this arrangement—which he views with the romanticism of youth—but Hanna is harder to understand, except that she becomes fixated on having him read to her. In fact, the only real emotion she evidences—apart from her slight amusement at his devotion to her—comes from her responses to what he reads. This all comes crashing down when Hanna is promoted from streetcar conductor to a clerical job—at which point she disappears.

What might have become little more than a bittersweet memory becomes something else when Michael—a law student in a class observing a war-crimes trial—discovers that Hanna is among those on trial for having been concentration camp guards. Horrified by this revelation and ashamed that he ever knew, let alone, loved this woman, Michael struggles with his conscience as to whether or not to speak up and convey a crucial piece of information he’s figured out about Hanna—one that would in no way clear her, but would have an impact on her sentencing. Michael loses this battle with himself and keeps quiet—for reasons that aren’t all that different from why Hanna joined the SS, ran away from her promotion etc.—and that moment defines his life and binds him to Hanna rather than frees him.

The older Michael (Ralph Fiennes) is a successful, but detached man. His marriage has failed. He’s uncomfortable with his own daughter. In every respect, he’s damaged goods—but not, as has been suggested, because of his teenage relationship with an older woman. He’s damaged because he chose not to do the right thing in order to hide his own personal shame, and he lives with that guilt on a daily basis—trying to assuage it as best he can by reading books onto tape and sending them to the imprisoned Hanna. What this ultimately leads to is something best left to the film. That the final scene may remind the viewer just a bit of the encounter between the aged Julianne Moore character and the Claire Danes character in The Hours is probably deliberate—as is the fact that the scene here is actually more hopeful, even if it comes from a source of greater despair.

Beautifully made, splendidly acted—this is the Kate Winslet performance to see, not the one in the upcoming Revolutionary Road—and of greater substance than most movies that come our way, The Reader poses some very difficult questions. These are questions it forces the viewer to ask him or herself, which also means it’s a somewhat uncomfortable film. However, it’s also a film that’s smart enough to know that it doesn’t have the answers to these questions and so leaves the answers to the viewer. Demanding? Yes. But that’s also why it’s such a worthwhile accomplishment. Rated R for some scenes of sexuality and nudity.

About Ken Hanke
Head film critic for Mountain Xpress from December 2000 until his death in June 2016. Author of books "Ken Russell's Films," "Charlie Chan at the Movies," "A Critical Guide to Horror Film Series," "Tim Burton: An Unauthorized Biography of the Filmmaker."

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

12 thoughts on “The Reader

  1. john r

    This was one of the most haunting movies I have seen. Watching how several characters respond to what was an infamous historical event left me with more questions than answers. What would I do in the same situation? Would I stand by and do nothing? Would I let someone take the blame, when I could prove them innocent? Who ultimately was victimized the most? This was a must see movie, and expect to spend some time discussing it afterwards.

  2. Ken Hanke

    I’ll second that.

    It’s interesting, but the other day (or night really), Justin settled in to watch this late night (he hadn’t seen it) and I told him that I might bail on him part way through, since I’d just seen it the week before. In the end, I watched the whole thing. I was too caught up with how well-crafted the screenplay was, how shrwedly Daldry directed it all, and how involved I was with the story. I actually admired it more the second time.

  3. Steven

    I’m seeing this tomorrow night. It hasn’t been getting that many outstanding reviews (besides yours of course).

  4. Ken Hanke

    I’m seeing this tomorrow night. It hasn’t been getting that many outstanding reviews (besides yours of course).

    If I recall, it’s in the 61% range of good reviews.

    Anyway, I don’t know what theater you’re going to tomorrow night, but there was a change (and I think a stupid one) after presstime in the Carmike 10 listings, and starting Friday The Reader is relegated to 1:00 and 4:00 p.m. only, so they can continue to bring you Twinklight in the evening. (And don’t yell at anybody locally — this sort of thing comes from corporate.)

  5. Ken Hanke

    I’m going to Carmike at 7:00. I thought the Twilight craze was over.

    I thought so, too, but apparently not quite — in someone’s mind. So as of tomorrow, there won’t be a 7:00 The Reader. Near as I can tell, after tonight, your only options are the Carmike matinees and the showings at the Co-Ed in Brevard (the times are staggered by days).

  6. Steven

    I can’t get over at how many people are complaining that this got nominated for Best Picture over The Dark Knight..

  7. Ken Hanke

    Oh, I am not surprised at all — about the complaints. The nomination was a (pleasant) surprise.

  8. Steven

    I didn’t realize it was playing at Grande Stadium. I’ve been wanting to see it again. Trying to figure out why this film has been getting quite a bit of negative reviews.

  9. luluthebeast

    This FINALLY came to our little theatre, and it will probably only be here a week. It was a superb movie; Mary was getting a little tired of it during the affair part, not knowing what was coming up, but when we got to the courtroom scene she was hooked as it all started to fall into place for her and was riveted by it.

  10. luluthebeast

    Well, I would say Asheville is a bit more cosmopolitan than Sturgeon Bay, especially off season!

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.