City of Asheville Voter Guide 2015

By Hayley Benton, Max Hunt, Virginia Daffron & Able Allen

Fifteen candidates are vying for three open seats on Asheville City Council. After the Oct. 6 primaries, those 15 will be reduced down to six.

The three seats up for grabs mark the end of Marc Hunt, Chris Pelly and Jan Davis’ four-year terms. Davis and Pelly have been on Council since 2003 and 2011, respectively, and only Vice Mayor Hunt is seeking re-election.

The Tuesday, Oct. 6 primary will reduce these 15 candidates down to six. And the night of Tuesday, Nov. 3, we’ll have our three winners. Just a friendly reminder: Those who show up and vote during the primary will eliminate nine candidates for the general election. Don’t let your favorite representatives slip through the cracks!

Xpress asked the 15 candidates a long list of questions — some open-ended, some yes-or-no and, for others, we asked them to keep their answers brief, in 10 words or fewer.

While the open-ended and short answer questions blew by painlessly, candidates seemed wary about answering a solid “yes” or “no” without giving further explanation. Xpress wants to acknowledge that we understand these questions are much more complicated than a simple yes or no. Not everything is in black and white. These questions were our attempt to get to the candidates’ root beliefs on these topics — only allowing them to answer yes, no, unsure or decline to answer the question altogether. Xpress asks readers to take this into consideration while reading the yes-or-no answers.

Table of Contents:

Candidate introductions:

Brief introductions, based on our 4×4 series. Be sure to visit each candidate’s full profile to view all answers by that individual — including our open-ended questions.



Click the image to view full-size.




For fun, Xpress also created a short quiz, so you, the voter, can compare your answers against the candidates. (It may ask you to log in at the end, but just click “View my result without account,” at the bottom, instead.)


Click the image to view full-size.


Corey AtkinsAtkins


While on scholarship at American University in Washington, D.C., Atkins developed a passion for fields that support the public interest. The future attorney then returned to North Carolina to attend law school at UNC Chapel Hill, moving on to an assistant district attorney position in Charlotte.

A first-time candidate for Asheville City Council, Atkins writes on his campaign site that, although there are many issues facing the city, “the issues we must focus on, in particular, are sustainable economic development, a citywide anti-discrimination policy and the relationship of our police force with the community.

“By addressing these issues,” he writes, “City Council can ensure that Asheville is a safe and inclusive community for everyone that visits or calls it home — something that is very important to me and my family.”

On economic development, Atkins writes, “I want investment from near and far to continue, but without losing the character that built Asheville. I want to promote small business growth and provide incentives and training to those individuals seeking to establish new businesses here. The city should collaborate with local organizations like Mountain BizWorks and Asheville SCORE in helping small businesses get a smooth start and grow effectively.”

Back to list.


Joe GradyGrady

    • Website:
    • Employment: Sales specialist & Community Commander at Best Buy, Former Keller Williams real estate broker; former City Council member in North Canton, Ohio.
    • Party affiliation: Registered unaffiliated, has voted in a democratic primary
    • Previous candidacy: Not in Asheville; was top vote-getter for 3 years in Ohio
    • For Joe’s full profile, click here.


Former real estate broker and former North Canton, Ohio city councilman Joe Grady has lived in North Carolina since 2000. Having served six years on North Canton’s City Council, 25 years in real estate and through his continuous work as a volunteer, Grady writes that one of his greatest passions is helping others.

After earning a bachelor’s degree in political science, American government and public relations from Ohio State University, Grady went on to earn a master’s in public administration from Phoenix University, where he wrote his thesis on affordable housing in Asheville.

“It is very clear that the affordable housing issue is a hot topic in this election,” Grady writes toXpress. “Is it the only issue? Absolutely not. … [But] I have worked with residential housing; I built residential housing for all income levels, including a senior housing development, and I studied affordable housing.”

Being a South Asheville resident, Grady writes that this is an area that has had “no representation on City Council for years. … When you look at South Asheville as the fastest residential growth area of the city, [it] concerns me that the entire Southern tier of of the city, that goes all the way to the airport, has no representation.”

In his spare time, Grady volunteers with his pet golden retriever, Beckett, a registered therapy dog, at Mission and Mission Children’s Hospitals, WNC Down’s Syndrome Buddywalk, Four Seasons Hospice, UNC Asheville and Deerfield Village Retirement Community.

Grady believes the biggest challenges facing Asheville are affordable housing, safety, city services, zoning changes, environmental concerns, taxes and beautification of the city.

Back to list.


Brian HaynesHaynes photobyStewartOShields

    • Website:
    • Employment: Showroom assistant manager at Habitat for Humanity
    • Party affiliation: Registered unaffiliated, votes in democratic primaries
    • For Brian’s full profile, click here.


Brian Haynes’ position is simple: to advocate for the people of Asheville and be “a good listener.”

“My family is my motivation for [running for Council],” says the lifelong Asheville resident. “I just want to see Asheville move in the right direction for [my children and grandchildren’s] futures.”

Former owner of the now-closed Almost Blue Records and The Basement bar, he and other like-minded entrepreneurs are credited with helping revitalize downtown, from a closed-up ghost town to a thriving epicenter for local business.

While Haynes cites affordable housing and the living wage as two of the biggest issues he hopes to tackle if elected, those two issues fall under one umbrella: “My biggest concern of all is that I think we’re growing at an incredible rate — and possibly too fast. … We invest more in growth than we do in citizens and the community and the town.

“We’ve still got huge infrastructure problems that aren’t being addressed,” he continues. “I just feel like we maybe need to slow the growth and take care of the problems that exist,” while still preserving “Asheville’s unique charm. It’s a unique city. If we bring in too many hotels and too many corporate chain stores, I think we could easily lose our charm and become just like any other city.”

Back to list.


Marc HuntHunt

    • Website:
    • Employment: Retired from Open Space Institute
    • Party affiliation: Democrat
    • Previous candidacy: Council member since 2011, vice mayor since 2013
    • For Marc’s full profile, click here.


Elected to Council in 2011 and serving as vice mayor since 2013, Hunt’s campaign site lists his accomplishments during his last four years, which include expanding the multimodal and greenway systems, supporting affordable housing initiatives and supporting economic development partnerships.

For the future, Hunt writes, “We must … renew what is already special [in Asheville] and add quality in new ways. This is especially true in regard to infrastructure: our parks, streets and sidewalks. We must reinforce the integrity of our residential neighborhoods, … continue to attract employers and great jobs that value community and … continue to elevate our commitment to the environment and [to] sustainability.

Back to list.


Rich LeeLee


Edward Jones financial adviser Rich Lee is a member of the East West Asheville neighborhood group and the City of Asheville Greenway Committee, chair of Buncombe County Triad and more.

Now, he’s also a candidate for the 2015 City Council elections.

Moving to Western North Carolina in 1997, Lee attended Western Carolina University, earning bachelor’s degrees in English and Spanish and a master’s in English. After graduation, Lee and his wife joined the Peace Corps, spending time in a small Jordanian village.

As part of his Council position, Lee advocates for bike lanes in West Asheville, installation of traffic calming lanes, Asheville’s affordability, job opportunities and social justice. His goals include growing the greenway system to connect underserved communities, taking back control of busy, dangerous roads, opening city-owned land for neighborhood uses (like trails and community gardens) and directing the hotel room-tax revenue to local needs.

On the last point, Lee writes, “Tourism should pay for the impacts of tourism on the community.”

Back to list.


Richard ListonListon


Richard Liston is admittedly “new to the political jungle,” he says. “This is my first expedition. I tend to do well when I set my mind to something.”

Liston received his bachelor’s degree from the North Carolina School of the Arts, one master’s from Eastman School of Music and another nine years later in computer science from Wake Forest University. He received his PhD in computer science from Georgia Tech in 2004.

He’s been a musician in North Carolina and New York City, a computer scientist in Research Triangle Park, a professor at a small liberal arts college and, most recently, an educator focusing on adult education, raising funds for Sphere College Project.

Since moving to the area in 2012, Liston has “gotten to know people in Asheville from all walks of life and heard their concerns,” he said to Xpress. “I think we are not as conscious as we need to be about the direction we are taking Asheville and about how wisely we are spending our money. I’m currently studying the system of Asheville and the city budget to decide what specific changes I would recommend.

As for getting his name out there, Liston says he doesn’t “plan to spend much money on advertising. I detest seeing the signs and litter created by it all. I plan to run my campaign by building a solid social network.”

Back to list.


Julie MayfieldMayfield


Julie Mayfield, co-director of MountainTrue, has worn many different hats in and out of the community. She’s an attorney, an advocate and a graduate of Leadership Asheville. She chairs the city’s Transit Committee and is a member of both the city’s Multimodal Transportation Commission and the WNC Chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union.

“I am a problem solver and a leader,” she writes on her campaign website. “My job for the last 20 years has been to work in the place of uncertainty and conflicting views and to find ways to move forward. … My career has given me the depth and breadth of experience to make progress on the challenges Asheville faces — how we grow, how we invest scarce dollars, how we take care of people and the environment and how we work together cooperatively and constructively.”

Some of her goals for Asheville include shutting down coal-burning power plants, adding more bus, pedestrian and biking infrastructure and balancing Asheville’s growth with preservation of our people, culture and environment to “ensure everyone — young and old, rich and poor, black and white — shares in Asheville’s success.”

Back to list.


John MiallMiall

    • Website:
    • Employment: Retired former city risk manager
    • Party affiliation: Democrat
    • Previous candidacy: Ran for mayor in 2013
    • For John’s full profile, click here.


In 2013, John Miall went head-to-head with now-Mayor Esther Manheimer, seeking the mayoral vote. Now he’s looking for a spot on Council. Miall graduated from UNC Asheville with a degree in political science and worked as the city’s risk management consultant for nearly 30 years before retiring in 2005.

In a press release, Miall writes, “Asheville continues to be a community of many robust and diverse ideals and interests. I do not believe the monopoly of a single political view represented by recent City Councils reflects that diversity. A voice of reason, restraint and experience is needed.

“I have seen and been part of government that put the public interest first, avoided the pitfalls of scandal after scandal, and balanced budgets without biennial tax increases. I believe Asheville is capable of better and certainly deserves better.”

If elected, Miall says he intends to work on setting a tax rate that reflects priorities “consistent with the role of local government,” including policing, fire protection, trash collection, paving streets and sidewalks and making the community safe. “Only after these core needs are met … should any city consider spending millions and millions of dollars on new development.”

Miall writes that he also wishes to diversify Asheville’s economy: “Tourism historically made Asheville the destination it remains for all of us, and will forever be a part of who we are, but the endless support of that one single element of our economy will continue to suppress wage earners and fail to create genuine employment opportunities. We can and should have both.”

Other goals Miall mentions include supporting city employees, fiscal responsibility and accountability, working with other local governments to sort out the water issues in the region, stopping excessive government spending on consultants and outside legal costs and reducing an “endless stream of regulation that frustrates small business [owners] and developers.”

Back to list.


Ken MichaloveMichalove

    • Employment: Retired
    • Party affiliation: Registered unaffiliated, votes in democratic primaries
    • Previous candidacy: Former Asheville mayor and city manager
    • For Ken’s full profile, click here.


Former Asheville Mayor and City Manager Ken Michalove’s resume includes four years as the executive director of the Buncombe County Planning Council, eight years as the city manager, four years as mayor and eight years total on City Council.

So, after a long run, why is he back? Michalove writes that recent Council actions have spent “an inordinate amount of time and money to satisfy [their own] special interest, … adopting tax increases that were not needed.”

He says he thinks that recent budgets were “not properly reviewed and challenged, … thus taxing the citizens of Asheville unnecessarily. …  The current City Council touts their support of affordable housing but raises taxes and fees unnecessarily.”

This, along with the “significant number of properties that are tax exempt,” he writes, hinders Asheville’s growth. If elected, Michalove says he’ll work to “create and preserve a tax base that can provide basic services and infrastructure.” On the most recent property tax increase, he says, “there is sufficient proof that, through proper management, that increase could have been avoided.”

Back to list.


Grant MillinMillin

    • Website:
    • Employment: Owner of Innovograph LLC
    • Party affiliation: Democrat
    • For Grant’s full profile, click here.


Grant Millin, founder of Innovograph, has a bachelor’s degree in sustainability and security studies from UNC Asheville and a master’s in project management and entrepreneurship from Western Carolina University. He is a GroWNC consortium member, City of Asheville Community Energy Plan member and a Leadership Asheville and City of Asheville Citizens’ Academy graduate.

In 1980, Millin’s parents bought the historic T.S. Morrison & Co,. hardware store, which today houses Lexington Avenue Brewery.

“A lot has changed in Asheville,” Millin writes. “I remember well the hard work it took to move from 1980 Asheville to where we are today.”

And, Millin tells Xpress, he hopes to keep pushing Asheville forward to a sustainable future.

Affordability, poverty and hunger make up the three sides of a single problem, he explains. And in order to address this and other problems, Millin’s “strategy is to create a more sustainable society.”

“For example,” he says, “the BB&T building was sold for a hotel condo project — that’s not sustainable tourism, there. We should have some good white collar, green collar jobs in that building. All those floors could be well paying jobs rather than a hotel condo.”

Some of his other goals include keeping government transparent, addressing issues of climate change and the environment and bringing tourists in to Asheville by passenger train, rather than clogging city garages with out-of-town cars.

Back to list.


Carl MumpowerMumpower

    • Website:
    • Employment: Clinical psychologist
    • Party affiliation: Republican
    • Previous candidacy: Former vice mayor and City Council member, 2001-09
    • For Carl’s full profile, click here.


Former vice mayor and city councilman from 2001 to 2009, Carl Mumpower has announced he’d like to make a comeback on the local political scene. Voted “best local villain” in the top two spots in Xpress’ Best of WNC poll for (at least) the last three years, Mumpower’s stark contrast to other council members’ views has made him the face of the ultra-conservative opinion in Asheville.

His Facebook campaign page, quoting Gen. George Patton, explains his view on the current Council’s often unified front: “If everyone is thinking alike, then somebody isn’t thinking.”

Some of his main stances for city government include: maintaining property tax levels, rather than raising them; not supporting economic development tax incentives or tax exemptions; accepting that Asheville cannot both cultivate an elite city for the rich and famous and maintain affordable housing for the average person at the same time; getting rid of Asheville’s “drug culture;” supporting a less politicized police force and less government interference in wages.

While on Council, Mumpower created and chaired the Asheville Public Artist of the Year program, the Memorial Stadium Restoration Committee, the Asheville-Buncombe Drug Commission, the For-Our-Kids public housing initiative and the Top-A-Stop bus stop rain-covers program.

Back to list.


LaVonda PaynePayne

    • Employment: Long-haul truck driver
    • Party affiliation: Registered unaffiliated
    • For LaVonda’s full profile, click here.


Xpress originally caught up with 23-year-old long-haul truck driver LaVonda Payne while she drove overnight through Ohio, making her way from Washington state to New York.

Payne sees herself as different than most candidates — for one, because she represents the youngest generation of Asheville adults, but also because she represents a demographic of citizens whose voice is not often heard.

“I’m really from this generation [of struggling locals],” Payne says. “I’ve taken the bus; I’ve been homeless. I’ve been hungry, and I had no one to help me. Sympathy and empathy only go so far in certain situations.”

She talks about people who ride the bus during multimodal initiatives, saying they “just did this as an experience.” At the end of the day, those people go home to their jobs, homes and cars. “Just because you took the bus, doesn’t mean you understand. You will never understand what it’s like. … We have all these people making decisions, but they have never had the experiences to make those decisions. They’re not even comprehending what’s wrong.”

And what is wrong?

“Asheville’s always been a tourist area,” she says, “but it’s gotten overwhelming. That’s the problem with upgrading: If your homegirl just got the new iPhone 6 and you’ve still got a flip phone, you’re going to feel the need to upgrade to feel equal. And that’s what’s happening with the city.”

Continuing her analogy, Payne explains, “Those flip phones never break, but iPhones do. Asheville was such a nice place back in the day. … Now we’re trying to compete with other cities, but we haven’t even taken care of our root-problems — our homelessness, our underprivileged kids. We’re sitting here trying to put on a front.

“I feel like people need to humble themselves and be like, ‘OK, we really do need to start taking care of our own before we start fronting for everybody else.’ … I feel like we’re losing ourselves and what we really stand for,” she continues.

Back to list.


Lindsey SimerlySimerly

    • Website:
    • Employment: Manager, WE DO campaign, Campaign for Southern Equality
    • Party affiliation: Democrat
    • Previous candidacy: Ran for Asheville City Council in 2007
    • For Lindsey’s full profile, click here.


Campaign for Southern Equality Campaign Manager Lindsey Simerly, who also chairs the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, ran unsuccessfully for City Council in 2007.

Back then, she was a student at A-B Tech and worked in construction, as a nanny and a massage therapist. Eight years later, she’s back, having added a lot to her resume. Simerly is a civil rights worker with experience in social justice issues and environmental and voter-rights advocacy.

“I understand why housing issues matter so desperately to families and working people in Asheville,” said Simerly. “I have 12 years of experience in policy making, organizing, collaborating and engaging the community right here in Asheville. Beyond this, I know what it means to struggle to get by in a city that’s becoming less affordable every day.”

Simerly is a campaign organizer for the Dogwood Alliance. And she coordinated and volunteered in campaigns for County Commissioner Brownie Newman, U.S. Rep. Heath Shuler, Councilman Gordon Smith and Commissioner Holly Jones.

Simerly says she also experienced what it’s like struggling to make ends meet in Asheville, and vows to “build upon my work as the chair of the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, advancing affordability and opportunity and … addressing issues of fairness and equality for LGBT people.

“Together we will make it possible for teachers, firefighters, baristas, hotel staff — for all of our neighbors — to have the opportunity to have a fair shot at a decent living, a safe home and a better life for their kids,” she writes.

Back to list.


Dee WilliamsWilliams

    • Website:
    • Employment: Small business consultant, real estate broker
    • Party affiliation: Registered unaffiliated, has voted in both democrat and republican primaries
    • Previous candidacy: Several unsuccessful bids for City Council, one for Buncombe County Board of Commissioners
    • For Dee’s full profile, click here.


Dee Williams is another familiar face on the list, as she too ran for Council in 2007 with the campaign slogan, “building a bridge to the overtaxed and the underserved in Asheville.”

Currently, Williams coordinates the region’s Ban the Box initiative, which seeks to eliminate the criminal history reporting requirement on job applications so that those who have paid their debts can move forward in life.

With a bachelor’s degree in public administration and political science from Winston-Salem State University and an associate’s degree in accounting and business administration from Blanton’s Business College, Williams aims to bring a market-based approach to tackling social concerns.

“We have to get at the root issue of so many of our problems, which is basic economic security,” she says. Her core concerns are economic security, affordable housing, food access and transportation options.

“This campaign is going to be about much more than catch phrases and buzz words,” Williams explains. “We are about turning ideas into action. Over the next few weeks, we will be rolling out a series of initiatives that will show (and not simply tell) how I will work for this community.”

Back to list.


Keith YoungYoung

    • Website:
    • Employment: Deputy clerk of Superior Court
    • Party affiliation: Democrat
    • Previous candidacy: Ran for Buncombe County Board of Commissioners in 2012, 2014
    • For Keith’s full profile, click here.


Another “back again” candidate, Deputy Clerk of Superior Court Keith Young will be on the ballot this fall after running unsuccessfully for county commission in 2012 and 2014.

Young received a bachelor’s degree in communications and design from Virginia State University and has worked in marketing and advertising for more than 13 years.

Growing up locally in a political household, Young says his interest in local government sparked at a very young age.

“I remember sitting around with party officials — we always talked politics in our household,” he explains. “It’s always been an interest of mine, being able to see how things change in society due to politics.”

Though Young has worn many different hats — he’s been a business owner and worked for Disney out of college — he says politics is one thing he’ll never get bored with.

“It’s in me,” he says. “It’s in me to want to help folks. … I know where real change comes from: Real change comes from activism. Real change comes from people going to the polls and voting. Real change comes from people being interested in their community. Real change comes from politicians understanding the constituents that they serve — and serving them in a way that will create growth for everyone. I know you can’t be all things for all people, but we can sure as hell try.”

Young’s main stances for the community are social justice, improved transit systems, connecting the greenways, increasing the housing stock for affordable development and strengthening the Police Department.

Back to list.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Hayley Benton
Current freelance journalist and artist. Former culture/entertainment reporter at the Asheville Citizen-Times and former news reporter at Mountain Xpress. Also a coffee drinker, bad photographer, teller of stupid jokes and maker-upper of words. I can be reached at hayleyebenton [at] Follow me @HayleyTweeet

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

41 thoughts on “City of Asheville Voter Guide 2015

    • Chris

      No one was curious about STR positions?? What is the pro / anti STR slate?

      • JT

        What is an “STR Position”? I googled it and am not finding a definition that pertains to Asheville or politics.

        • Short Term Rentals – a highly contested issue that MountainX managed to overlook. Haynes, Lee and Young want locals to be allowed to rent properties short term to garner some income from their biggest investment. Hunt and Mayfield like the $500 per day fine Hunt convinced my fellow Council members to approve (Pelly voted no with me). And Hunt pushed through hiring of a rental “cop” who is going to cruise the Web searching for people offering STRs on AirBnB, VRBO, etc. and etc.

      • Haynes, Lee and Young want locals to be allowed to rent properties short term to garner some income from their biggest investment.

  1. Lulz

    LOL at Hunt and the need for sidewalks in his neighborhood. Fails to mention that it isn’t Grace where he lives. It’s right there on Cambridge where someone just bought a house and tore it down just to build another to their specs. In his neighborhood, the price of housing is irrelevant. The road he lives on is nice and wide and freshly repaved along with new water pipes. And don’t even mention how much diversity IT LACKS. It should be named white bread central LOL. But he’s a democrat so he sure does identify with the working poor and every other made up farce that politicians come up with.

    Same goes for some of the others running that are employed in non-profits and are squarely a burden on taxpayers. Yet somehow feel qualified to spend money that they themselves cannot EARN outside of handouts. And that goes double for the breweries who not only are here to get money from taxes, but also put a huge strain on resources from water to law enforcement. Which of course is billed to property owners who cannot afford the increases.

        • JPM

          Not to a time / place but back from the brink of insolvency. We are spending way more than we have and beinnial tax increases and even faster escalating fees speak to the course we are on. Building our tax base and providing essential core services FIRST then anything else can be considered. It is in my mind “needs” versus “wants.” Priorities.

      • Amen from me too, however the price of housing is relevant in every neighborhood and we clearly need to unzone his and build highrise condos there.

  2. Grant Milin

    I’d like to share my thoughts on what I actually said in place of Mountain Xpress’ ‘declined to answer yes/no’ boxes in their 2015 Voter Guide. Hunt, Mayfield, Simerly, Lee, Haynes, and Young all are trapped in one way or another by Cecil/SLG and how MX is trying to shape the question of developing city-owned land.

    I’m happy to help set a fresh course. I live here too and am seeing a really slow, ineffective approach to dealing with our challenges right now and am glad I joined this race. Not everything is a protest story. I have the mix of political knowledge and general strategy technique building up the Next New Deal I feel sure most really want these days.

    Selling off public property wholesale is part of libertarian fantasy where governments like City of Asheville end up being the mayor and an assistant in a small office. It’s true drawing the line in the sand needs to happen now when it comes to the commercialization of everything.

    But we’ve got this land that is not headed to parkland right now at 68-76 Haywood Street. It’s also just one high priority matter facing Asheville. That’s really what’s wrong with this election cycle.

  3. Jaded Local

    Good coverage of the candidate, but given that there are so many to sort through and given that early voting began a week ago, perhaps MX could have run it in an earlier issue.

    • We were planning on running it last week (9/23), but held off because that turned out to be such a large issue (with our Women Shaping WNC coverage). But thanks for the feedback! We’ll definitely try to get earlier coverage in next time.

      • Thank you. My letter to the editor would have been better informed if I had had the article while writing it. I wouldn’t have supported Grady.

    • Grant Milin

      I point out how the supposed ‘top six liberals’ fell into a trap around the SLG agenda… which is really an agenda about fears of selling public land. I certainly am not about cutting public economy assets and benefits, but something the brings the community together and has long-term sustainability value beyond just a park only is best for the property in question.

      City council is boxed in, but there’s still plenty of innovation maneuvering space… if we choose to go there

  4. OneWhoKnows

    Rich Lee is scared to come on the WWNC 570 morning talker show NOR the afternoon Pete Kaliner show, and he verbally harrassed an armed VETERAN who was standing guard at the military recruitment office in West Avl. WHY is RICH LEE scared of WWNC guys ??? huh?

    AVOID voting for the evil progressives Julie Mayfield, incumbent Marc Hunt and Rich Lee! We don’t need any more progressives trying to DICTATE to the citizens and RAISE TAXES forever! ENOUGH of their kind!

    • bsummers


      • OneWhoKnows

        No Barry, all CAPS is more difficult to read …

        and why is Gordo so gaga over Rich Lee ???

  5. Thank you Ms Benton Benton for an excellent, issue based voting article and especially for the wonderful, issue based scorecard! I only wish it was early enough to better inform my letter to the editor, which is now in print but not yet online. I also wish there was more housing policy on the scorecard, but it was covered elsewhere in the article. When I filled out your scorecard, Dee Williams and Corey Atkins did much better than I expected, and Joe Grady did much worse; causing me to regret supporting Grady in my letter.

    • Hey Alan!

      So glad you liked the coverage!

      I just want to remind you (and other readers) that, although we think that the scorecard/online quiz could certainly be helpful for making a decision, that you should go with whichever candidate makes the most sense to you. After all, the scorecard was only based on the yes or no questions. I’d advise you to look through the open-ended and short-answer questions and factor those into your decision as well.

      • voting by the scorecard alone is probably ten times better than the resume basis on which most voters vote and most candidates campaign, and a hundred times better than not voting, which is what over 90% of Ashvillians do.

  6. I stand by my support for Payne and Liston in my letter. Simerly again did well on the issues, but she is tainted by the rude, insular online clique around Gordon and Lee. These insiders talk a lot better than they act.

  7. bsummers

    What was the worst thing to happen to Asheville in the last two years?

    Julie Mayfield: “The legislation taking Asheville’s water.”

    Well, why didn’t you do anything to try & stop it? We would have loved the help.

      • bsummers

        Not much. Julie and the Alliance gave the bare minimum of support to some of the things that our little ad hoc group initiated, like the petition. But as for taking any sort of lead or effective action, they were AWOL.

        • Peter Robbins

          At Julie’s ineffectual urging, I stood for hours on a street corner waving a sign for some Asheville water-control issue that didn’t affect me in the slightest and about which I knew next to nothing. Sorry to have been such a disappointment to your little group. I’ll try not to do it again.

          • bsummers

            I appreciate you coming, and I’m sorry if it sounded like I was disparaging the efforts of WNC Alliance members and supporters. I probably should have been clearer.

            In her capacity as WNCA director, with all the political and institutional clout that comes with that, Julie failed to come out swinging for Asheville when the State came for our water system. As I said, after we initiated actions like the petition, the rallies etc., she would give a measure of support – it would have been conspicuous not to. But she initiated nothing much on her own, and our more aggressive strategies, she either walked away from, tried to get us to scale back, or outright set herself in opposition.

            Here’s an example: some may remember that in 2012, before the actual seizure bill, Mssrs. Moffitt, McGrady and Ramsey got passed a precursor MSD bill, that set the stage for the seizure to come.


            Our group was urging people to lobby then-Gov. Bev Perdue to veto this bill. Asheville’s City Council voted unanimously to lobby Perdue to veto it. Julie Mayfield lobbied Bev Perdue not to veto the bill. And in fact, that’s what Perdue wound up doing – she allowed the bill to take effect without her signature. Had they been forced to come back and override the veto, or re-file it next session, with the public awareness that what was really behind it was the seizure of Asheville’s water, it might have gone down differently. But we’ll never know. Julie worked behind the scenes against what we and City Council were trying to do.

            Her argument was that vetoing it wouldn’t have a practical effect – the GOPers had enough votes to override; that we needed her to keep her political powder dry for other vetoes to come; and most significantly to me: that having the bill vetoed would just make McGrady, Moffitt & Ramsey mad, and things would get even worse.

            This was a trend that I perceived quite often in our discussions, that boiled down to: don’t do things that will make Chuck McGrady mad. When Mountain Voices Alliance proposed a forum at Jubilee that would give real opponents of the water seizure a voice that McGrady & crew would have to respond to – Julie tried to get us to cancel it. We went ahead with it, and that wound up being the most direct confrontation with Asheville residents that Moffitt and McGrady ever got. Katie Hicks of Clean Water, Joe Minicozzi of the Downtown Association, Council members Hunt and Davis, myself and others were on a panel with them that they couldn’t run away from. It was beautiful – and Julie had tried to stop it.

            And this was the tone in our behind the scenes working group. Paraphrased comments from Julie:

            “We can trust Chuck to keep the bill from getting as bad as Moffitt wants it to be.”
            “We can trust Chuck to put things in the bill that we want – environmental protections, etc.”
            “I just had breakfast with Chuck, and he tells us that this is the best offer that the City will get.”

            And this is was the real jaw-dropper:

            “At the end of the day, I think we’ll be really glad that Chuck is working on this bill.”

            It got so bad that we had to ask Julie to stop meeting with Chuck and acting as if she was negotiating for us.

            There’s more, but you get the idea. I came away convinced that it was more important to Julie to protect her relationship with Chuck McGrady, the one “good” Republican on the environment (and the political clout within the enviro community that came with that) than it was to really fight hard for the City of Asheville.

            Was she deliberately selling us out, or was she simply a incredibly bad strategist who failed to read the political players and winds properly? I don’t know. I just know that she’s absolutely the last person who should be on City Council at this important time for Asheville.

          • Peter Robbins

            Having counted to ten, I will accept your sort-of apology and file your ensuing remarks in the drawer reserved for tactical disagreements amongst allies, some of whom occasionally get too close to an issue to express themselves with precision or wisdom. I trust this approach will allow you to dismount the high horse with a modicum of dignity. But I caution you, sir: do not ask people to sign petitions and attend rallies and such if you do not consider those activities to be important and effective contributions to the cause. It does not make for credible coalition-building.

          • bsummers

            Thank you. Again, I only meant to point out Julie’s tepid & sometimes counter-productive involvement in fighting the water issue, not WNCA supporters, several of whom are key members of our SaveOurWaterWNC group. Poor initial choice of words on my part.

          • Peter Robbins

            Okay. But you did squander a lot of hyperbole to get down to such a tepid and counter-productive point.

          • bsummers

            OK, you’re still mad. It’s my point that’s tepid and counter-productive?

            Julie was practically (if not absolutely) working against us and the City on the water issue. She had to appear to be supportive, but in the places it really counted, she was protecting her relationship with Chuck. And Chuck is a master at bullying, as we’ve seen.

            Given that this relationship (Chuck, the State, and the City of Asheville) will play a huge role for the next several years at least, I would rather not have someone on Council whose judgement on that relationship is in question.

          • Peter Robbins

            Yeah, I heard you the first time. And the second. And the third. The wine doesn’t improve with age. I understand your argument, but I would prefer to see the smartest, best educated, most accomplished and most sensible candidate win one of the three city council spots. Even if some good people differ with her about how a weak and almost certainly losing hand should have been played a few years ago. Whatcha gonna do? Tastes vary.

            And I’m not mad. When I’m mad the comments magically disappear. I’m not sure how that works.

          • bsummers

            Even if some good people differ with her about how a weak and almost certainly losing hand should have been played a few years ago.

            Are you suggesting Julie Mayfield threw Asheville under the bus on the water issue because she perceived it was a “losing hand”? Wow, that’s what I figured too. Friends like her, we hardly need Chuck McGrady.

            Whatcha gonna do?

            Oh, I dunno… NOT throw Asheville under the bus?

            Thanks for the confirmation.

  8. I am also surprised by how low the candidates scored on the online quiz. I think Atkins won that with about 30% and all but 4 candidates got 0%. I guess politicians just suck.

  9. I’d repeat that the designers of the Quiz were very poorly informed about City law and City issues, and managed to miss the really difficult issues that face elected officials in Asheville. Not helpful at all.

  10. In fairness, the quiz was a lot better than all the talk of resumes and “qualifications”. At least it was issue based and that is VERY refreshing just in itself. Yes it could better address the toughest issues dividing us, like parks vs rents.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.