MSD board meeting mixes humor and politics

A seemingly straightforward meeting of the board of the Metropolitan Sewerage District of Buncombe County took two surprising turns on Wednesday afternoon. One led to a tongue-in-cheek staff report on a private sewer-line failure that took more than two years to resolve. The other led to a vote on withdrawing a December proposal to the city of Asheville regarding the possible merger of water and sewer management — an action that was rejected.

The meeting moved at a fast clip until Tom Hartye, general manager, was tapped for his report. Hartye briefly outlined the private sewer rehabilitation process the agency has operated for some years, identifying and bringing into the system certain failing private distribution lines. Staff members Ken Stines and Mike Stamey, collection system construction and maintenance directors, then took over with an illustrated report on a worst-case scenario — an actual episode of private-line failure involving several families and more than two years of negotiation. MSD ultimately had to call on the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources, the Buncombe County Health Department, The Mediation Center, and the Buncombe sheriff (and some watchful deputies). The story pointed out how complicated problem-solving can become, as well as how seriously staff must take safety. But the good-humored narrative left the board and audience chuckling.

Hartye then took up several business issues, including the agency’s standing in the recently released University of North Carolina Environmental Finance Center’s 2012 report on financial performance benchmarks for water and wastewater. He noted that the district performed “at or near the highest level for every benchmark.” (The full report is available here.)

Billy Clarke, the agency’s attorney, updated the board on the status of current legislation (HB 488) requiring consolidation of the Asheville water system and MSD, and creating a regional water and sewerage district entity to replace the existing MSD. Clarke highlighted several features of the current version of the bill (which has passed in the House and is now under consideration in the Senate). He noted that it transfers all assets and outstanding debts of the public water system to MSD, and in turn transfers all assets and outstanding debts of MSD to the new MWSD created by the bill. The MWSD would be governed by a 15-member board (the current 12 seats plus three members from Henderson County).

Clarke said a change has been made in the bill that will require the approval of municipalities when any construction takes place in their jurisdiction. “I think that would be cumbersome,” he told the board. “There’s some language in there you need to work with.”

Following Clarke’s review, board member Glenn Kelly, Biltmore Forest commissioner and MSD representative, brought up the board’s December proposal to the city, offering — among other things —  a $57 million cash settlement for the prospective merger of the two systems. The letter to the city came under an earlier legislative directive that no forced-merger legislation would be filed if the parties were negotiating a merger “in good faith.” Because the new legislation requires direct transfer of assets without compensation, and because there had never been a response from the city, say MSD officials, Kelly said the MSD offer “ought to be withdrawn.” He moved for withdrawal, effective immediately. The motion was seconded by Bill Stanley, former commissioner and continuing Buncombe County representative.

Discussion included an a question from Asheville appointee Bill Russell, former Asheville council member, as to whether negotiations and “the efforts of the last 18 months,” were now off the table because of the new bill.

“Once it’s enacted,” responded Asheville Vice Mayor Esther Manheimer, MSD board member as well as city negotiator regarding the legislatively proposed merger. She added that she had seen the MSD board’s December action as more of a “study” than a proposal, and she commented that withdrawing the negotiation figure of $57 million would be “fairly mean-spirited … but I understand the rationale.”

“I’d want to know if there is a real risk to withdrawing,” said Steve Aceto, board chair and Montreat representative. “My understanding is that we did intend that to be an offer [but] as it turned out, there really was no negotiation at all that I could identify, other than the letter … but I’m very concerned about withdrawing that unless there’s a real and present danger not to.”

Kelly’s motion was eventually defeated on a 4-7 vote, with Kelly, Stanley, Woodfin Mayor Jerry Vehaun and Woodfin Water & Sewer District representative Jackie Bryson favoring withdrawal.

by Nelda Holder, contributing editor

UPDATE: An earlier version of this story incorrectly reported that Buncombe County Commissioner Joe Belcher voted in favor of withdrawal of MSD’s negotiation letter. According to MSD’s general manager, the fourth favorable vote in the voice count was instead by Jackie Bryson, as corrected above.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

12 thoughts on “MSD board meeting mixes humor and politics

  1. bsummers

    “I’ve put together an aggregation of 13 years of articles, some video links and Wikipage link on Asheville water system.”

    How civic-minded of you. Did you include the video of the Feb. 2012 Mountain Voices Alliance Forum at Jubilee which included, in the words of the MVA Chair:

    “Powerful statements and/or presentations from NC Reps. Tim Moffitt, Chuck McGrady, and Susan Fisher; Buncombe County Commission Chairman David Gantt; City Councilmen Jan Davis and Marc Hunt; Asheville Downtown Association Ex. Dir. Joe Minicozzi; Clean Water for NC Assoc. Dir. Katie Hicks; Warren Wilson Economics Prof. Susan Kask; and Asheville activist Barry Summers.”?

    Oh right, sorry. You deliberately erased all record of that event.

  2. bsummers

    The forum was minimally covered by the XPress, hence the word “highlights” in the article.

    The three-hour videotape of the forum, entrusted to Davyne by Mountain Voices Alliance, had much more than the ‘highlights’. Perhaps that’s why it was destroyed.

  3. bsummers

    Again, and this will be my last comment – it was not my video. I had nothing to do with recruiting you to record it or anything else. It was created by Mountain Voices Alliance, the many panelists, and members of the public. It belonged to the citizens of this region as part of the record on this important issue. Thanks for confirming that you erased it & deprived it from them deliberately.

  4. Illuminatti_01

    Mr. Summers, wasn’t your water blog where the video was linked? Yet you felt you had no responsibility to be civil to Ms. Dial, when she’d put in hours to set up, record, edit and host video that you used to link to?

    Your insulting, ingrate behavior resulted in Ms.Dial removing the video. That’s a consequence of your behavior.

    Besides, no more was revealed in that Jubilee forum that has not been revealed ad nauseum elsewhere.
    I was there so I know.

  5. bsummers


    Can you tell me what “insulting ingrate behavior” of mine supposedly caused Ms. Dial to erase the video of that forum? You sound clued in, so please do tell.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.