Former Commissioner Bill Stanley linked to Buncombe corruption

Bill Stanley
DOWN THE LINE: Former Buncombe County Commissioner Bill Stanley, second from right, is the second former Buncombe elected official to be accused of participating in improper county government activity connected to former County Manager Wanda Greene and her associates. Photo by Margaret Hester

A second elected official has been implicated in the ongoing federal investigation of Buncombe County corruption. Speaking at a Dec. 17 meeting of the county Board of Commissioners, attorney Ron Payne said that former Commissioner Bill Stanley had been accused by former Assistant County Manager Jon Creighton of improperly accepting unspecified “things of value” from former county contractor Joseph Wiseman Jr.

Payne said Creighton made the allegations in a sworn deposition he provided before reporting in October for an 18-month sentence at USP McCreary, a federal prison in Kentucky. While Creighton and Wiseman, along with former Buncombe officials Wanda Greene, Michael Greene and Mandy Stone, were convicted of federal corruption charges on Aug. 28, former Commissioner Ellen Frost is the only other elected official yet formally accused of participating in improper county government activity.

In response to Creighton’s testimony, the commissioners unanimously voted to remove Stanley’s name from the William H. Stanley Center, host to the county’s Family Justice Center and other government offices. The building will henceforth be known by its previous name of 35 Woodfin St.

According to a letter provided to the county by Stanley’s family dated Oct. 14, he “is unable to admit or deny allegations made against him concerning his tenure on the Board of Commissioners.” The letter continues that the family “respects the work and investigation of Commissioner Stanley and others for past acts” and accepts the county’s decision to strip his name from 35 Woodfin.

As of press time, no federal criminal charges had been filed against Stanley in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina. The board also did not announce any civil proceedings against the former commissioner; at the same meeting, Payne said that the county had filed a lawsuit against Frost and Greene to recover taxpayer funds that were allegedly misdirected to out-of-county equestrian activities.

Commission questions

During his update to the board, Payne provided a letter detailing the results of interviews he and his colleague Philip Anderson had conducted with current and former commissioners regarding their connections to Wiseman. He said that no one interviewed had recalled meeting Wiseman or seeing him at county-related events.

However, Payne added that some of the commissioners may have unknowingly benefited from Wiseman’s largesse. After some meals at conferences attended by county representatives, he said, “Ms. Greene or Mr. Creighton would call Mr. Wiseman and have him phone in his credit card number to pay for meals when Ms. Greene was afraid that it would be so much that the public would get upset.”

Payne said that four former commissioners had not made themselves available for interviews about any dealings with Wiseman: Frost, Stanley, David Young and Nathan Ramsey. Contacted by Xpress after the meeting, Young wrote that he did not meet with Payne “because I have no knowledge of any wrongdoing by me or any other commissioners. I have not served as commissioner for 11 years.”

In an email message to Xpress, Ramsey wrote that he had spoken with Payne by phone about a month ago. During that conversation, Ramsey said, he shared that he “had no awareness of Joe Wiseman until I read news reports about him” in connection with the Buncombe corruption scandal.

“Mr. Payne has my mobile phone/email and he can contact me any time and can ask any questions to me he desires,” Ramsey added. “If I was aware that anyone connected with Buncombe County government acted improperly, I would have already contacted the U.S. Attorney’s Office and shared that information with them.”

Payne noted that the county is currently seeking a court order to compel financial records from Wiseman’s employer before 2014, CDM Smith, to gain further details about his alleged gifts to Buncombe officials. Once those records are received, Payne said, Wiseman’s deposition will be taken to guide further investigation.

In other news

The board unanimously approved nearly $1.18 million in additional spending for the East Asheville Library, bringing the project’s total cost to roughly $6.98 million. The library had previously received an additional $1.3 million in November 2018 after community members called for an expanded facility and different site.

The new allocation contains over $223,000 for features dubbed “optional alternates,” including nearly $75,000 for an exterior courtyard and over $36,000 for wood trim. After Commissioner Joe Belcher asked if all those features were truly necessary, Library Director Jim Blanton responded with a passionate defense of the building’s design.

“Our library buildings need to be inspiring. They need to be a place where people come and experience joy and delight and are inspired to learn and be a part of this space,” Blanton said. “You have to want to go back to that building over and over again. And you really have to pay attention to aesthetics because of that — otherwise, we would just build a gymnasium or something.”

Commissioners also approved $372,000 for new Americans with Disabilities Act-compliant voting machines and agreed to donate a $240,000 federal grant for greenway design to the city of Asheville. The county will still provide $20,000 of its own funds as part of a required $60,000 local match for the grant, with the remainder provided by the city and nonprofit greenway advocacy organization Connect Buncombe.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Daniel Walton
Daniel Walton is the former news editor of Mountain Xpress. His work has also appeared in Sierra, The Guardian, and Civil Eats, among other national and regional publications. Follow me @DanielWWalton

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

14 thoughts on “Former Commissioner Bill Stanley linked to Buncombe corruption

  1. Karen Smith

    Whattaya know…another domino going down. Who’s next? Anyone want to bet?

  2. Joseph

    Any commissioner, Brownie Newman, Jasmine Beech Ferrara, Al Whitesides etc, or a person with oversight AKA Buncombe County Attorney Michael Frue who failed to notice an entrenched culture of theft and entitlement on a massive scale that went on for years should be forced out of office or fired. It is absolutely stunning that Newman and Ferrara have the audacity to run for re-election and that Frue is still collecting public dollars.

  3. Bb

    This all broke right after Jasmine Beech Ferrara got into office, there was no lack of oversight on her part!

  4. Larry McDuffie

    That’s what happens when you have one party rule for 100 years.

  5. Keith Thomson

    These Commissioners who have been successfully cleaning up the mess and recovering public money misused by former County staff are the ones who *should* run for reelection. Their commitment to the educational opportunities of our children and workforce, investing in community infrastructure, accessible housing, and jobs is why we need them to serve.

    • K Smith

      These commissioners that allowed it to go on under their noses *should* run? Bwaaaahaaaa. Yes, by all means. Keep the clown car rolling.

    • Keith Thomson

      The Commissioners named in the , very selectively, Brownie Newman, Jasmine Beech Ferrara, Al Whitesides, have been the solution, not the long term problem from trusint the staff, who to give the devil its due, had maintained a AAA bond rating.

      • K Smith

        The commissioners named in the what..? And what or who is the “trusint staff”. Sheesh. Brownie was there when the big money was walking out the door. If commissioners don’t oversee, why pay to have them at all?

    • Keith Thomson

      The selective part of the criticism here is failure to mention Mike Fryar, Joe Belcher, and Robert Pressley, all of whom have served as long or longer than the other names mentioned. Should they all resign as well? The recovery of money from the Insurance policies, civil claims, and other means taken by the current commissioners against the former staff, who were removed and subsequently convicted of wrongdoing, have been achieved under the sitting commissioners. Procedures to limit future risks of such behavior have been implemented under the current commissioners. Brownie became chair, and Jasmine and Al were sworn into office, only seven months before Wanda was removed.

  6. bsummers

    How’s that study on whether to do a study of getting water from Canton coming?

  7. Concerned Citizen

    …as a former employee who didn’t embezzle or get paid high dollars…I find it odd that Frue or Flora haven’t wound up being part of anything. It was a common rumor that both were big friends with Wanda. Frue actually being put in a high paid stand by position doing nothing until a position could be created or vacated for him…

  8. Meredith Hunt

    So, Stanley is guilty by accusation until proven innocent. It’s a dangerous trend.

    • Lulz

      I wouldn’t say guilty by association. After all, the cult members are defending the current crop of corruption still on the commission. But what you should realize is they’re eating their own hoping it doesn’t reach them. Eventually it’ll all come out and I fully expect some more names to drop.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.