Theater review: ‘Elf: The Musical’ sparkles like tinsel

OH, BUDDY! Elf: The Musical returns to the Asheville Community Theatre for a second consecutive year. Actor Carson Fox, pictured, also returns, reprising his role as Buddy. Photo by Eli Cunningham

Asheville Community Theatre was packed on opening night and gleaming with holiday excitement as Elf: The Musical took the stage for the second year in a row. The production, which made its debut on Broadway in 2010, was written by Thomas Meehan and Bob Martin with music by Matthew Sklar and lyrics by Chad Beguelin. Its ACT return runs through Saturday, Dec. 23.

The theatrical musical is based on the 2003 film version, Elf, memorably starring Will Ferrell, James Caan and Zoey Deschanel. The movie quickly gained distinction as a modern Christmas classic. Its adaptation to the stage is effective and mostly remains faithful to the source material.

After accidentally being transported to the North Pole as an infant, Buddy (Carson Fox in his reprised role) is raised as an elf by Santa (Greg Austin) and Mrs. Claus (Jessica Garland Lowe, who doubles as the show’s choreographer). Now an adult, Santa informs Buddy of his true identity and further reveals that his unknowing father, Walter Hobbs (Scott Cameron), lives in New York City. Buddy leaves the enchanted North Pole to find him. Stuffed in his stocking satchel is the only thing to guide him — a snow globe featuring the Empire State Building, where his father works. When Buddy arrives to Walter’s office, the sight of a flamboyantly dressed man-child elf does not sit well with Walter. When Buddy explains who he is and that he’s arrived from the North Pole, Walter and his staff think the visitor is mentally unstable. Can Buddy soften his workaholic father’s hardened heart, or is he destined to be orphaned all over again? 

From its start, ACT’s production of Elf: The Musical is brimming with bright promise and jovial energy. It is both fun for children and, because of some innuendos, entertaining for adults. Lowe’s choreography in the production also helps adds a peppy quality to the songs. Standouts include ACT’s rendition of  “Nobody Cares About Santa,” which is lively and fun, and the more touching number, “I’ll Believe in You.” The latter requires complete emotional surrender to land an effective delivery, which cast members Anderson Ford and Mara Breindel strived to achieve in their roles as Michael and Emily Hobbs, respectively.  

Fox’s return to the role of Buddy seems inevitable. His expressions and big eyes instantly make you fall for the character. But his talent goes beyond the physical. The role requires balance. Had Fox played Buddy as a caricature, the entire play would have faltered. Furthermore, Fox has to present the character in a way that does not come across as psychotic. If his innocence were overplayed, this could have been cringeworthy. Without question, the charming Fox is undeniably wonderful here.

Elly Leidner also delivers a lovely performance as Buddy’s unlikely girlfriend, Jovie. There’s an ’80s vibe to her portrayal, calling to mind Mary Stuart Masterson‘s underdog role as Watts in the 1987 film Some Kind of Wonderful. Leidner makes her lovelorn character relatable and someone to root for. It’s a joy to see her in each scene. Because of her striking presence, Leidner has the potential to become a viable film star. Meanwhile, Zach Shackleford, a newcomer to ACT’s stage, is similarly alluring. He plays the gruff department store manager where Buddy winds up working. Here’s hoping we see more of Shackleford in productions to come.

While the brisk pacing is noteworthy, the production noticeably lost its traction just before intermission. It’s as if something backstage or unseen by the audience altered the high-flying energy of the performance. Because of this, the rhythm of the show was altered, and the acting onstage felt rushed and cautious. In particular, the momentous emotional explosion between Walter and Buddy lacked the powerful heart-rendering feeling needed to enter Act 2 effectively. This can happen sometimes in live productions and quite possibly was a fluke. Thankfully, the show regained its footing before too long, and the verve was restored.

Director Mark Jones does an incredible job adorning this production with immense spirit, alongside music director Kristen Johnson Dominguez. The costume design by Ida deserves considerable praise as well for its balance of realism and quirkiness. Additional kudos goes to the ACT for allowing cast members to keep their edgy, individual styles. For years in the performance arts, many actors did not earn a role because of unfair judgment linked to tattoos, piercings and hairstyles.

With the return of Elf: The Musical, ACT clearly has a holiday hit on its hands … again. And based on comments offered by staff during the curtain speech, it seems likely the production will return next year. More 2023 shows have already been added to accommodate public interest. And while this impulse to bring Elf back each year is understandable, one has to wonder what other great Christmas shows could be rotated in to keep it fresh.

But for now, Elf: The Musical is the holiday production. It has a big heart and dazzling production values, all of which sparkles like tinsel. Those who manage to catch a showing will experience a Christmas wish come true.  

What: Elf: The Musical
Where: Asheville Community Theatre, 35 E. Walnut St.
When: Through Saturday, Dec. 23, with performances Thursday-Saturday at 7:30 p.m.; Saturday and Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets $18-$36.50


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Kai Elijah Hamilton
Kai Elijah Hamilton was born and raised in Western North Carolina. A poet, screenwriter and playwright, he is also a published film and theater critic. Hamilton is a creative individual with a wide range of talents and interests. He is an Award Winning Actor (Tom in "The Glass Menagerie") and Director ("A Raisin In The Sun"). He previously served as Artistic Director at Hendersonville Little Theatre and has a B.A. in theater and film from Western Carolina University. In 2016, Hamilton's play "The Sleepwalker" won a spot in the first annual Asheville National 10-Minute Play Festival by NYS3. His play "Blackberry Winter" was a finalist in the elite Strawberry One-Act Festival in NYC winning Best Short Film/Video Diary. Hamilton is also the author of the full-length southern-gothic play "Dry Weather Wind" which has been called "Important. Relevant to the issues in today's time, and beautifully written..."

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

One thought on “Theater review: ‘Elf: The Musical’ sparkles like tinsel

  1. Woodrow

    I had a delightful time seeing Elf last weekend, but I feel the need to criticize Kai Elijah Hamilton’s choice of singling out Zachary Shackleford as the only ensemble member worth praising. Zachary is fine, but if you’re going to make a point of giving him a special shoutout, you really should mention some of the other ensemble such as Naimah Coleman who was hilarious as Deb and brought heaps of refreshing personality to the Hobbs office. You should mention Pluto Churchill who did an admirable job of balancing their performances as the zany Charlie the Elf and the grizzled Macy’s Santa. You should mention Evan Brooks, who brings their A-game on all fronts to both this production and Elf Jr, in which they play the leading role of Buddy. You should probably just praise the entire ensemble, who all worked just hard and worked *together* to make this show as fantastic as it was, instead of making a point to give another cis white male a pat on the back for showing up. It’s almost 2024 and you need to do better.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.