A house divided in the N.C. Statehouse

The proposed new districts for Statehouse and the Buncombe County Board of Commissioners could further polarize both the legislative delegation and local voters.

Released the evening of July 12, the new maps place Democratic Reps. Susan Fisher and Patsy Keever in the same district (the 114th, which now includes most of Asheville), potentially pitting them against each other in a primary next year. Republican Rep. Tim Moffitt‘s newly drawn 116th District stretches from Arden in the south to Sandy Mush in the northwest, essentially doing an end run around Asheville. Similarly, a new, more conservative 115th District extends from Fairview to Barnardsville in eastern Buncombe County.

Fisher and Keever say the new lines, drawn by GOP leaders in Raleigh with little input even from Redistricting Committee members, were designed to force one of the two legislators out.

“This is obviously a Republican attempt to draw Democrats out of office and dilute our influence,” charges Fisher. Keever, meanwhile, declares, “They want to pile all the progressives into the city and have two [other] districts, in hopes of adding a Republican.”

Asheville City Council member Esther Manheimer, a Democrat who served as a redistricting lawyer when her party controlled the General Assembly, says this is a tried-and-true strategy.

“You’d rather have one city district and then two county districts around it, because you want to pack in your left-leaning voters as much as you can and not let them infect another district to a high degree,” she explains.

But the prior maps, stresses Manheimer, were also the product of political strategy. “If you look at Buncombe and how the House districts are drawn here, it’s not a mistake that all three districts come into the city: That’s an attempt to dilute the conservative county vote, to try to ensure that there’s three Democratic seats.”

Moffitt overcame that handicap last year, ousting incumbent Jane Whilden by a respectable margin. And the new battle lines, he maintains, are “fair, logical and very legal. …

“I think most reasonable people would agree that the urban areas are consistent with their line of thought in a lot of ways, and the more rural areas are consistent with their line of thought. This is a balanced way for everyone to at least be recognized with a seat at the table,” Moffitt asserts.

The one thing Moffitt and his Democratic colleagues seem to agree on is that they had no say in the proposal. Despite belonging to the party in power and serving on the House Redistricting Committee, Moffitt says he had “zero voice in this process.”

“Nothing was transparent,” says Keever, who urged local voters to make their opinions known at a July 18 public hearing at A-B Tech. Fisher also rallied supporters, encouraging them to attend the hearing, noting, “They released the maps in the evening, when the news cycle would be off, so they wouldn’t get nearly as much of a bashing as they might have ordinarily.”

Incumbent commissioners also now in competition

Due to a change in local election law engineered in Raleigh back in May, the new Statehouse districts will also apply to the Buncombe County commissioners, formerly chosen via at-large elections (see “Balancing Act,” June 22 Xpress). The new maps could put several current board members (all of whom are Democrats) at loggerheads.

Vice Chair Bill Stanley and Commissioner Holly Jones both live in the proposed 114th District. Commissioners K. Ray Bailey and Carol Peterson are both in the 115th. The board chair (currently Democrat David Gantt) will continue to be elected countywide. All five incumbents face re-election next year.

The new law also expanded the board to seven members. During next year’s transition, each district will elect two commissioners: The winner gets a four-year term and the runner-up two years (after that, the elections will be staggered). Thus, while both incumbents in the 114th and 115th districts could still be re-elected, they might find themselves competing for the four-year term.

With Democrats outnumbering Republicans in the 114th 32,439 to 10,906, both of those commissioners, and the state legislator, will probably be Democrats. But the district’s liberal demographics suggest that a more left-leaning candidate could displace one of the incumbents. Asheville City Council member Brownie Newman is rumored to be considering a run; he announced July 15 that he won’t seek re-election to Council.

The picture gets murkier in the 115th, with 22,594 Democrats, 17,340 Republicans and 15,289 unaffiliated voters. And with Keever now moved to the 114th, her former district has no incumbent heading into next year’s election.

And the 116th has the most conservative demographics: Under the new maps, the district would lose 2,704 Democrats (leaving it with 20,198) and 223 Republicans (leaving it with 18,611). According to State Board of Elections data, however, the 14,786 unaffiliated voters tend to swing Republican: In 2008, voters from those precincts gave John McCain 53.99 percent of their ballots compared with 44.86 percent for Barack Obama.

Moves and countermoves

The current commissioners unanimously opposed the switch to district elections, which was spearheaded by Moffitt. Gantt had said they were considering a November referendum to re-establish at-large elections before the district elections could be held. Legal consultants advised against it, however.

“It’s disappointing; it’s not what I’d like to hear, but the state is sovereign in North Carolina, and we have to live with that, reluctantly,” Gantt says now. “The way the constitution is written, it looks like we’re probably going to have to deal with the new system, and we’ll do the best we can with what we have to work with.”

Moffitt, however, maintains that whichever way the lines are drawn, district elections are “a good way to make sure county residents have a voice at the table. David [Gantt] knows that with at-large elections, the backroom strategy for any political campaign in the county, from the beginning of time, is that all you have to do is win the city vote, and … you win the seat. … I don’t ultimately think that’s the fairest thing to our county residents.”

Meanwhile, the state Democratic Party is expected to mount a legal challenge, and both Keever and Fisher are on board. Though Keever first claimed state office last year after slaying fellow Democrat Bruce Goforth in a primary duel, she says she has no desire to oppose Fisher.

“If we do run against each other, it’s going to be very difficult, because we … both think the other one’s doing a great job,” Keever explains. “It might be the world’s cleanest campaign. But I think it’s way too early to say what’s going to happen. We’re not accepting that this is the way it’s going to be.”

— Jake Frankel can be reached at 251-1333, ext. 115, or at jfrankel@mountainx.com.

Redistricting Special Coverage:


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Jake Frankel
Jake Frankel is an award-winning journalist who enjoys covering a wide range of topics, from politics and government to business, education and entertainment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

3 thoughts on “A house divided in the N.C. Statehouse

  1. Keith Thomson

    “Moffitt, however, maintains that whichever way the lines are drawn, district elections are “a good way to make sure county residents have a voice at the table.”

    We should always remind ourselves that ALL of those who live in the six Buncombe County municipalities- Montreat, Black Mountain, Weaverville, Woodfin, Asheville and Biltmore Forest– also live in the County, and pay the same county tax rate as those who live in unincorporated areas. Moffitt chooses to ignore that fact in conducting his war on Asheville.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.