Rep. Moffitt proposes legislation seizing Asheville water system ***Updated 4:15 p.m. Thursday***

Republican state Rep. Tim Moffitt has filed legislation that would seize Asheville’s water system, turning control over to the Metropolitan Sewerage District. Asheville City Council member Bill Russell, who also sits on the MSD board, said Moffitt didn’t inform either body before proposing the legislation.

While the legislation doesn’t mention Asheville by name, it specifies “a city with a population of over 75,000 according to the most recent decennial federal census is located within a county with a population of 200,000 or over according to the most recent decennial federal census.” If the legislation passes the General Assembly, the city would have to give its entire water system to MSD within one year, and would be prohibited from operating a water system ever again.

Vice Mayor Brownie Newman says he, Council member Esther Manheimer and City Manager Gary Jackson met with Moffitt for 30 minutes during a trip to Raleigh on May 2, and the legislator did not mention the water-system bill.

“It’s baffling,” Newman tells Xpress. “It’s one thing not to be proactive, but when people have travelled four hours to see you, to talk about the issues we need to work on, it’s strange to not even mention that there’s going to be a bill to seize a water system that the city has operated for the last 100 years.”

“This was out of the blue; there was no discussion about it,” Newman says. “I’m opposed to it, I think Council will be opposed to it. It’s frankly pretty outrageous that a legislator would propose such a far-reaching piece of legislation without consulting us.”

“I would have liked to have some discussions,” Russell tells Xpress. “I’ve been on the MSD board for three and a half years and I’m certainly a big fan of consolidation and saving money. But I think there would have been a better process.”

Instead, Russell says he found out about the legislation last night, in an email from Newman.

“I had no clue, and I don’t think anybody did,” Russell added. “It’s not necessarily something I’m opposed to, but it’s like ‘wow.’ The city’s spent tens of millions of dollars investing in the infrastructure for our water department, we’ve done a lot of work over the last seven years to repair it and make good our promise when we took over the authority. To suddenly have it legislatively stripped out from under us without any public or open dialogue is certainly not a process I’m a big fan of.”

Russell also says that “if you want to hand it to the MSD, you may want to see if they can handle it in the first place.”

The city of Asheville gained control of the water system in 2005, after the dissolution of the regional water authority. Shortly afterwards, state legislation (the Sullivan Acts) sharply restricted what rates Asheville could charge, prevented it from using water service for purposes of annexation and restricted how it could spend system revenues (though those last restrictions were relaxed some in ensuing years).

Newman says he sees “no compelling reason” for the legislation and that despite the 2005 disputes between the city and Buncombe County, the city has invested $30 million in capital improvements to the water system and the issue is no longer a controversial one between the two parties.

“I simply see no basis for this, there’s been no calls from anyone in the community to do something like this,” Newman says. “Since then [2005] there’s really been no controversy about how the system has been managed. There’s no movement to do something like this.”

As for the city’s response, “we’re going to fight this,” Newman says.

The legislation is the latest proposed state law that seeks to take assets from local government, reverse moves it has made or change the way it functions. Moffitt also proposed legislation that reverses the 2005 Biltmore Lake annexation and another bill that, without local referendum, changes the way the Buncombe County Board of Commissioners are elected (both bills passed the House).

He also joined with local Democratic Reps. Patsy Keever and Susan Fisher in proposing legislation that would seize the Asheville Regional Airport and turn it over to an independent authority. The election changes were unanimously opposed by the commissioners and the airport legislation was unanimously condemned by Asheville City Council. At the same meeting, Council members also expressed their anger at the General Assembly’s approach, asserting legislators have not consulted them before proposing the bills.

However, Russell, an independent, added that in his view, “the GOP has put up with the Democrats forcing legislation for 200 years. It should be no surprise some things are going to come out of this assembly a little more forceful than it should be, and probably not quite as palatable to Democrats. I just wish we could sit down and say there’s a better way for this sort of legislation to be drafted, and a little bipartisan help would be good.”

— David Forbes, senior news reporter


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

14 thoughts on “Rep. Moffitt proposes legislation seizing Asheville water system ***Updated 4:15 p.m. Thursday***

  1. tatuaje

    I love how these people run on ‘smaller government’ platforms and then IMMEDIATELY make government bigger and take the decision making process out of the hands of the citizens that it effects.

    Hey timpeck, isn’t that the exact opposite of what you believe in and why you supported Moffitt!??!?

  2. LOKEL

    How are all of these “proposals” legal …. how can Moffitt propose legislation that is specific to one City or one County ….

  3. tatuaje


    He didn’t, he just happened to specify criteria that Asheville ‘happens’ to match perfectly.

  4. WitchDoctor

    Well, Tim, that’s what you would have thought that Moffit would have wanted… until he actually got elected. Everybody seems to be against “big government” until “big government” is doing what they want.

  5. Barry Summers

    There’s no mystery to me what this is really about: privatization. Moffitt is a member of the American Legislative Exchange Council, and one of their focuses is privatizing everything from schools to prisons to public utilities. Forcing the City to hand it over to the MSD is merely a necessary first step. Why else wouldn’t they have consulted with the MSD to see if they could even handle the water system long-term?

    “Steve Aceto, chairman of the MSC board, said he knew nothing about the measure until this morning.”

    Tim Moffitt wants to hand over control of our life-giving drinking water supply to whatever greedy corporation ponies up the money. Mark my words.

  6. luther blissett

    Turns out that Tim Moffitt thinks he got elected as Buncombe County Dictator.

  7. sharpleycladd

    Moffitt doesn’t believe in government, and is stealing everything that’s not nailed down. We’ll be mailing our water payments to a private, for-profit corporation soon. It’s pure thievery, and people like Moffitt and Tim Peck should be ashamed of themselves.

  8. sharpleycladd

    You know, I’m a “job creator.” 17 full- and part-time positions, hourlies 9.88 and up for part-timers, annuals in the 28-40K + health insurance range for full-timers. I am sick and tired of parasites in the Republican Looter’s Party stealing stuff that I paid for with my tax dollars and handing it over to their friends. In Michigan, they’re dissolving entire city governments, handing city parks to their developer friends, and turning public land into private golf courses. It’s all wrapped up in rhetoric about self-reliance, and it’s true, I suppose, that thieves are self-reliant: they steal. I’m really tired of being told what “job creators” want from society by a bunch of thieves and people who win lawsuits and live off of the proceeds, coddling their consciences with phony Randian lies, unwilling to face their startling resemblances to Reagan’s “welfare queens.”

  9. J

    Remember when Brownie and company held public discussions about dissolving the county-city water deal, because I don’t.

    Barry, how is this privatizing anything?

  10. selena

    Tim Moffitt also happens to be the founder, owner and CEO of an executive search firm. My guess is that he already has some folks lined up to head these “independent authorities” – after all what rich executive wouldn’t want a high-paying, power-rich job tailor-made for him in our beautiful area? And he won’t just turn them over to any old greedy corporation, it will be greedy corporations on whose boards he or his family members will sit. This is how power/financial empires are made.

  11. Bjorn

    Why does it seem that all Politicians (in my opinion) are paid whores for Corporate America…? No offense to those seeking office or paid sex workers.-B

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.