Council, activists at odds on climate emergency resolution

NO TIME TO WAIT: Ashley McDermott, one of the founding members of the Asheville chapter of the Sunrise Movement, addresses a crowd of about 300 people during the Global Climate Strike on Sept. 20. Photo by Brooke Randle

As temperatures plummeted during the Nov. 12 meeting of Asheville City Council, Mayor Esther Manheimer announced some hot news for local climate activists: Council members will vote on a resolution declaring a climate emergency during their meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 26.   

“Thanks to everyone who’s been involved in that process, and we look forward for that resolution to come before this council at the next meeting,” Manheimer said, referring to the numerous speakers who have inundated Council members with demands for the resolution since August.

Efforts to persuade Council to make the declaration have been primarily spearheaded by the Asheville chapter of the Sunrise Movement, a national youth-led campaign to fight climate change and promote the Green New Deal, a legislative proposal to address climate change and economic inequality.

Despite the group’s apparent success, Ashley McDermott, a founding member of the Sunrise Movement’s Asheville chapter, said after the meeting that she was caught off guard by the mayor’s announcement. Her organization and city staff, she added, were “far from being in alignment” on the specifics of the resolution. 

In a Nov. 13 group statement to Xpress, Sunrise members wrote that Council’s decision to add the climate emergency resolution to the Nov. 26 meeting seemed “presumptuous” because its terms were still being discussed with the city’s Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment. SACEE is expected to take up the issue during its next meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 20.

“There’s much to be done on this resolution if we’re going to come to an agreement, so for the mayor to share that publicly feels like we’re being sidestepped in a process we initiated,” the organization members wrote. 

The group continued that the resolution must not be “declaration for the sake of optics” and should be designed to generate tangible results. “The purpose of this would be to produce a Climate Justice Plan (or, essentially, a municipal Green New Deal) that shifts the framework for how we approach our budget and city planning process,” the statement read. “Without these changes to assure accountability, timeline, transparency, education and bringing voices from the community to the table, we will not support this resolution moving forward, and it should not be brought to a vote.”

Manheimer told Xpress in a Nov. 13 email after the meeting that she is prepared to postpone the vote for the resolution if Sunrise Movement representatives and city staff do not come to an agreement about the resolution’s language and impact.

“I was of the understanding that SACEE and Sunrise were in productive conversation about the wording of the resolution and felt Council would be able to consider the resolution at our next meeting,”  Manheimer wrote.  “Again, if that is not the case, the Council can certainly wait to consider the resolution.”

In other business

Council also voted to approve a more than $400,000 contract for the construction of a new fire station on city-owned property at 316 Broadway in North Asheville, which will include room to house three firetrucks, an emergency operations center, an administrative and operations space, and a community room. 

The new fire station aims to improve service response in the Five Points, Montford, UNC Asheville and Richmond Hill communities. Funding for the facility had previously been allocated in this fiscal year’s budget through the city’s Capital Improvement Program. Construction for Fire Station 13 is scheduled to begin next fall and take about a year to complete.  

 Council beefed up supplies for the Asheville Police Department by agreeing to match a more than $25,000 U.S. Department of Justice Bulletproof Vest Partnership Grant to purchase 78 vests for APD officers. Council also authorized the city manager to procure a more than $50,000 handheld X-ray imager for Asheville’s High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas/Drug Enforcement Administration Task Force to aid in detecting concealed items in vehicles. The equipment will be paid for using existing funds from the 2018 HIDTA grant.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

6 thoughts on “Council, activists at odds on climate emergency resolution

  1. Enlightened Enigma

    So WHAT is the PLAN for when these people STOP the climate from changing? then what ?

    Don’t waste Maoyor’s time with this BS…

  2. C-Law

    Sunrise is funded primarily by Soros and corporate $$$…definitely not grassroots.

    Typical leftist virtue signaling…

    PS—anyone care to laugh odds McDermott is some former English or Womyn’s Studies major…never held held a private sector job in her life, but probably volunteered or worked for numerous Democrat campaigns….?? Hmm? ha ha!

      • C-Law

        Counter Culture hope you have a pen, pencil, notebook, and a sack lunch…cause I’m about to take you to school kid! ha!

        Sunrise is funded by the Rockefeller Fanily Fund, Wallace Global Initiative and Soros Center for American Progress money…at least 55%, if not greater (sunrise isn’t required to fully disclose funding sources at this time)…other funds come through other ngo/nonprofit fronts that are also funded by the globalist finance totalitarians.

        Re:McDermott’s CV…English degree from libtastic Elon U. Check! :)
        Job description—Communications, Narrative Building (“newspeak” for crafting propaganda, ha ha!), and Campaign Management…check! Ha! :)

        Since 2010–independent consultant, presumably self-employed!? And when exactly did she graduate from Elon? So, yeah then, ummm when has this person ever actually held a real job in the private sector? Check!! ha! :). By the by, Counter Culture why don’t ya dig in a little and share with us how many failed local Democrat political campaigns McDermott has managed? You seem smart, spill the tea for us. Okay, so I’ve achieved the MtnX mercy rule level of winning for the single post refutation argument so I’ll stop here and sum up…

        Counter Culture—your post is total failure on all fronts…please don’t get triggered too hard, your participation award is in the email, and you at least did try to have something to say, so good for you! :)

        Bottom line is that you, McDermott, Sunrise, et al., are totally wasting your time and energy cause banning cow farts, airplanes, and tilting against the windmill of established solar maximum and minimum cycles is the sort of wackadoo bs that does not resonate with the vast, vast majority of functional, reasonable, working adults in America. You have picked a fight you can not and will not ever win. Do something useful with yourself like help out ABCCM Veterans Quarters assisting homeless veterans this winter…I might run into you there and we could get a laugh about banning cow farts versus actually helping out real human beings here in our local community.

        • Virginia Daffron

          Let’s stick to the substance of the issue — whether or not the City Council should pass a resolution declaring a climate emergency — rather than the CVs of individuals on whatever side of the debate.

  3. Gordon Smith

    Local group seeks resolution recognizing science. This is not controversial, unless you have conspiracy theorists who want to talk about something other than climate science. Then they will talk shadowy whatnot in conspiratorial ways.

    The good news is that the science is right here for everyone to read! Whether you’re George Soros or Gordon Smith:

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.