An exceptional treasure

The city of Asheville should pull the plug on plans to build a National Guard armory in Richmond Hill Park. It’s becoming increasingly clear that this is simply the wrong place to put such a facility.

The land given to the National Guard in exchange for grading work includes several hundred feet of Smith Creek, which has already been adversely affected by sediment because of the Guard’s failure to use best-management practices during construction of the parking lot for the park. Any further damage at the armory site will impact the entire creek as it flows through the park.

The current plans also include a field-maintenance shop with a rack for washing vehicles, and the Guard’s own environmental assessment recognizes the likelihood of spills and leaks of hazardous materials, erosion and sediment-loading in Smith Creek. All this should give the city serious reservations about moving forward as planned.

Here’s why the city should nullify its contract with the National Guard:

1. The Guard’s environmental assessment failed to acknowledge Richmond Hill Park’s ecological value and significant resources, including species listed by the North Carolina Natural Heritage Program and the N.C. Wildlife Resources Commission as species of concern.

2. The grading work performed by National Guardsmen at Richmond Hill was not conducted according to the site plans.

3. The grading work did not abide by state and local erosion-control laws designed to prevent runoff into waterways.

4. The Guard was unable to correct the construction work within the standard 30-day time frame set by the state Department of Environment and Natural Resources.

5. As a result, the city had to spend an additional $50,000 bringing in an outside firm to correct the work performed by the Guard.

6. The original agreement was based on the Guard’s providing an estimated $1 million worth of grading work in exchange for the land. Much of this work was never done because of significant problems in protecting Smith Creek from runoff and the extent of the environmental degradation that was occurring.

7. The Guard has already received about $23,000 from the sale of timber removed from the armory site.

8. The closest interstate access to the armory would be via Riverside Drive—one of the first local roads to flood during big storms.

9. Having Richmond Hill Park bordered by a “25-meter antiterrorism/force protection security buffer,” as described in the environmental assessment, is inappropriate for such a unique and valuable natural area.

10. Richmond Hill Park is priceless and should be recognized for what it is: Asheville’s premier urban forest!

The ball fields have been scratched from the plans due to the steep slopes, prior environmental missteps and concerns about traffic in the Richmond Hill neighborhood. Instead, the city should site these facilities along Riverside Drive, which would create more public space along the riverfront and provide safer, more convenient access for young athletes and their families while protecting water quality and making Asheville more beautiful.

We know we need to preserve the natural heritage of our mountains, and Richmond Hill Park’s high-quality forests and streams are best suited as a refuge for wildlife and families looking to escape from the stresses of modern life, and as an outdoor classroom for teaching children about the natural world they live in and are part of. Beautiful wildflowers, abundant wildlife and cool forest breezes make Richmond Hill Park an exceptional treasure that’s unique in our city parks system. The recent discovery of the Southern zigzag salamander—the fourth special-status species found in the park to date—only underscores its remarkable biodiversity.

Simply put, this irreplaceable forest treasure is too precious to be lost to shortsighted development pressures. And despite the mistakes already made, Asheville can still rise to a higher level of environmental awareness and stewardship. Tell City Council you want Richmond Hill Park back—and the plans for the armory canceled!

[James Wood, a UNCA graduate with majors in environmental science and biology, enjoys using Richmond Hill Park for jogging, dog walking, studying, disc golf and escaping the stresses of everyday life.]

About Webmaster
Mountain Xpress Webmaster Follow me @MXWebTeam

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

2 thoughts on “An exceptional treasure

  1. E. Adams

    I now live in Richmond Hill, just a short walk from where the proposed armory is set to be. I moved here in the midst of all the clamor about the park, but I had never been to it so I didn’t feel too strongly about what should happen. Well, now that it has been opened and I’ve had a chance to explore it with my 2 year old boy, I see what a blessed wonderland it is. I find the placement of the Armory to be absurd, right next to a retirement home, and many residential homes, and at the end of a small street.
    My son and I also discovered the creek that Mr. Woods calls Smith Creek, and it is a little gem. My son can occupy himself almost indefinitely by throwing rocks and watching the water flow down.

    It does seem that the armory placement would block access to this creek, or at least make it very difficult to get to.
    I say keep Richmond hill park as natural as possible now. I do feel that now that so many trees have been removed, they should make creative use of that open space. Like picknic benches or a little play ground so the very young can be busy while some of their elders can play disc golf. I bet we could petition Warren Wilson to build it as a comunity service project.

  2. Peter Brezny

    I am very hopeful that city council will do it’s best to acknowledge the mistakes that have been made and work to have the armory built in another location. It’s obviously the right thing to do, however, this council doesn’t have such a good track record with admitting and correcting development mistakes. Just look at Campus Crest, Staples, Greenlife, Walmart,…the list goes on. All developments that still violate the UDO in one area or another, all have been brought to council’s attention for review, and to the best of my knowledge, none fully resolved.

    There is a chance now that Scot Shuford is gone that the staff at least will have the chance to do the right thing. Hopefully, with enough encouragement from those who care more about their communities quality of life and sustainability, this council will do the right thing, and take action to preserve the park indefinitely.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.