It’s long past time we ended pointless wars

Bruce Carruthers


On Sept. 21, the world observes an International Day of Peace, initiated by the United Nations 40 years ago. This will be the 12th year that Asheville has joined others on the planet in solidarity, hoping that someday, peace may prevail on Earth. Even amid Western North Carolina’s stunning beauty, we can’t help but consider the tragic events in Afghanistan, the pointless sacrifices made by local military personnel and the incalculable suffering inflicted on noncombatants.

By the most conservative estimates, 71,000 civilians have perished in Afghanistan in two decades of war, along with an equivalent number of Afghan military personnel, and there are an estimated 2.5 million Afghan refugees worldwide.

North Carolina ranks high on the list of states with the most military deaths, particularly in proportion to the state’s population. But deaths don’t tell the whole story. In the post-9/11 wars, more than 50,000 U.S. military personnel have been officially listed as wounded, and thousands still suffer from the effects of exposure to toxic burn pits, traumatic brain injuries, PTSD, sexual trauma, moral injury and other conditions related to serving in a combat zone. Meanwhile, more than 30,000 veterans and active-duty military have taken their own lives since the beginning of the war on terror. Four times as many military personnel and veterans have died by their own hand as have died from combat. Suicides among North Carolina veterans are nearly 40% higher than among civilians.

The war at home

Homelessness is a national problem, but for veterans in our area, it’s especially acute. According to Homeward Bound, a local nonprofit working to end homelessness, 40% of Buncombe County’s homeless folks are veterans, compared with 11% nationwide. Many of them suffer from effects of the militarization of our foreign policy. They’ve served in our endless wars, and they find the adjustment to civilian life overwhelming. In many ways, only fellow veterans can understand the trauma of military service and what the nation’s constant war-making does to the young men and women of Western North Carolina and the country as a whole.

Local veterans are fortunate to have access to the award-winning Charles George VA Medical Center. In 2018, it served over 47,000 WNC veterans, providing over 300,000 outpatient visits, 8,500 emergency room visits and nearly 1,000 hospital admissions. Those statistics drive home the human cost of our military “adventures.” Veterans have earned the care the Charles George affords them, but how much better would it be if we pursued peace and didn’t ask our citizens to participate in military actions the world over?

According to some accounts, the U.S. has nearly 800 overseas military bases spread across five continents, at an annual cost of $85 billion to $100 billion. Imagine if those resources and the cost of veterans’ care were directed to addressing the very real problems we face both nationally and across North Carolina, including right here. In some Tar Heel counties, child poverty rates are around 40%, and with few exceptions, the rates in WNC counties exceed the national average. Shouldn’t lifting our children from poverty be one of our highest priorities?

Senseless waste

What have Ashevilleans learned from all this? Do we at last we see the futility and tragedy of war? Our terrible technological instruments of destruction, some of which include parts made here in Buncombe County, have killed tens of thousands of men, women and children, wounded countless more and created millions of refugees. And unless we cease fighting such wars, those numbers will only continue to rise once Pratt & Whitney makes its footprint along the ancient French Broad River.

Meanwhile, thousands of U.S. veterans, many of them our sons and daughters here in Western North Carolina, will suffer from physical and psychological injuries for the rest of their lives.

The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have each cost at least $2 trillion, and if you factor in the interest charges and the cost of caring for those veterans, it could add trillions more. For the current fiscal year alone, the Department of Veterans Affairs’ budget is $240 billion.

Just consider how that money could have been used to directly benefit our fellow citizens. WNC residents need health insurance, education and job training, and our region continues to see rapid growth, putting increasing pressure on a health care system that’s already grappling with the COVID-19 pandemic and the opioid epidemic. Our infrastructure is decaying, while efforts to create sustainable, renewable energy seem stalled.

Just say no to permanent war

Have we in here in WNC learned anything from our failed wars in the Middle East and our endless military interventions in other nations? Will we and our fellow citizens nationwide finally grasp the limits and failure of military power?

After our debacle in Vietnam, I felt certain that the U.S. had learned its lesson and would henceforth turn to diplomacy instead of war to solve problems. But I was wrong: Within just a few short years, my country was again engaged in pointless and destructive wars that have brought us and the citizens of the countries we’ve invaded and occupied nothing but injury, death and destruction.

Will we learn from the failure in Afghanistan, or will we continue on the same path? This is a central question, both for us and for our children’s and grandchildren’s futures. According to, North Carolina taxpayers are spending $16.23 billion on the military in 2021 alone. Just imagine if that money were directed toward addressing the local impacts of our biggest enemy: global climate change.

I invite you to consider these questions during this year’s International Day of Peace — and to join us in working toward the day when peace will indeed prevail, as the Peace Pole in downtown Asheville’s Elder and Sage Community Garden reminds us in English, Korean, Spanish and Cherokee. We’ll meet via Zoom at noon Tuesday, Sept. 21.

Bruce Carruthers is a Vietnam veteran and retired Veterans Affairs employee. A member of Veterans for Peace Chapter 099, he lives in Waynesville. For more information, visit WNC4Peace’s Facebook page.


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

7 thoughts on “It’s long past time we ended pointless wars

  1. indy499

    Your simplistic just say no to war is as silly as Nancy’s just say no to drugs.
    I regret reading your long post. I thought you might have something nuanced to say. If you think diplomacy is the only tool in the tool box we’ll fail.

    • Bruce Cameron Carruthers

      Thanks for your comment. My point is that our endless wars have not only failed to accomplish their missions, they have had the opposite effect. Our huge military has accomplished little to nothing, and it is time to try other approaches. In addition, the trillions of dollars we spend on war making could be better directed to the needs of our citizens, such as healthcare, infrastructure, education, the environment, etc.

      • indy499

        Your point wasn’t so deep that anyone couldn’t get it. It’s just simplistic. Great war is better than no war. Duh. How does one accomplish that in a world where people want to conquer neighbors and impose their will is a different story.

        • Bruce Cameron Carruthers

          You still don’t get my point, and I believe your simply don’t want to. So, good luck with your great wars.

  2. Big Al

    As a Desert Storm era vet, I actually agree with Carruthers. Our last several conflicts, from Somalia to Iraq and Afghanistan, has shown that while the USA, under the leadership of both neoconservatives and moderate Democrats have demonstrated a willingness to try and free people from perceived oppression, we have demonstrated an incredible lack of understanding of the true nature of the cultures within which those people exist.

    Those starving Somalis were more than happy to shoot westerners and drag their bodies through the streets when we tried to impose peace on them from the outside, even to prevent starvation. The various tribes that we liberated from Saddam Hussein turned on us in a heart beat when we failed to place their tribe in charge of “those other dogs”. And the Afghans (or at least the men, the only people who matter there) are EMBRACING the Taliban’s militant Islam rather than our idealistic goals of empowering women and religious minorities, and embracing Western ideals of civil liberties.

    We would be much better off leaving these nations alone to grow out of their feudal ways and THEN offer a hand to help them develop civil societies. Our attitude of “just send in the Marines” and “bomb them back to the stone age” have not only failed, they have cost us too much of our treasure and blood, and for no effect. Both parties are equally to blame and all Americans (myself included) have fallen for the fallacy that the world is just waiting for a savior and that savior must be us.

    And let’s not forget that the short-sighted, immature and amateurish Trump administration all but destroyed the trust of our NATO allies that took decades to build and maintain, and may take decades to rebuild.

  3. indy499

    Big Al, you mean our Nato allies who we pay with blood and $ to protect? It won’t take decades pal. They are back under our umbrella already as long as we pay tp protect them. Trump’s a dummy but only the eastern europeans who actually know about the commies firsthand pay their assigned nato cost share. Rich Germany can’t afford their committedf 2%? Give me a break.

  4. Robert

    Yahoo News Video
    U.S. successfully flight-tests Raytheon hypersonic weapon, Pentagon says

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.