Bothwell slams Rogers over payday loan industry donations

With election day, May 8, approaching fast, Cecil Bothwell is bashing his main rival in the 11th Congressional District Democratic primary, Hayden Rogers, for taking campaign donations from the payday loan industry.

Bothwell and other critics of the industry say it profits from predatory lending that targets young and low-income workers.

The Bothwell campaign sent out a press release May 2 asserting that Rogers has accepted $17,500 in campaign donations from individuals, lobbyists and special-interest groups associated with the industry. While the donations are legal, Bothwell notes that the industry isn’t legally allowed to operate in North Carolina. And in the press release, Bothwell rhetorically asks the pointed question: “Why is a candidate from N.C. attracting and accepting so much money from an industry banned in N.C.?”

In contrast, Bothwell, who also serves on Asheville City Council, notes that his campaign “will accept no money from corporations or corporate PACs.” And in a television ad –— his first of the primary campaign — Bothwell looks directly in to the camera, declaring: “I won’t take one penny from corporations or their lobbyists because I believe you need a congressman who represents you — not the fat cats. My Washington-insider opponent has taken thousands of dollars from the payday loan industry, a form of predatory lending that’s been banned in North Carolina. Hayden Rogers represents everything that’s wrong in Washington, D.C.”

Watch the Bothwell ad here:

But Andrew Whalen, consultant to the Rogers campaign, brushes off the attacks, countering that Bothwell “has been angry and negative throughout the campaign.”

Whalen adds: “This is just the latest petty and desperate attempt at an attack from a candidate who knows he’s about to lose.”

Rogers, longtime chief of staff for incumbent Democratic 11th District Rep. Heath Shuler, raised just over $300,000 for the campaign, compared to Bothwell’s roughly $75,000. The Rogers campaign notes that nearly $200,000 of the total was contributed by individuals, with more than 55 percent given by donors who live in Western North Carolina.

Whalen also points out that Bothwell was issued a warning April 27 by the Federal Election Commission for failure to file a timely finance report. “For a campaign that likes to talk about transparency and openness, they should file their reports when required by law,” he asserts.


For immediate release: May 2, 2012
What: Payday lenders fund Rogers’ NC 11 campaign
From: Bothwell for Congress

The Bothwell for Congress campaign will accept no money from corporations or corporate PACs. Our campaign is entirely funded by individuals. (The committee donation listed on our campaign finance reports is Bothwell for Buncombe, funded by individuals for Bothwell’s local races in 2008 and 2009). Our opponent has taken tens of thousands of dollars from lobbyists and PACs. The most questionable sources are payday lenders.

Hayden Rogers has accepted $17,500 from individuals, lobbyists and special interest groups associated with the Payday Loan Industry. All of these donors are from outside of North Carolina, hailing from places such as Las Vegas, Miami, and South Carolina. They are all from out-of-state because North Carolina banned the Payday Loan Industry in 2001.

It took until 2006 to fully shut down the industry (which played a cat and mouse game exploiting loopholes, changing names, etc.). In a 2006 press release NC Attorney General Roy Cooper said: “We’ve fought payday lending at every turn and now we’re putting this industry out of business here in North Carolina. These payday lenders thought they’d found a way around North Carolina law. Now we’re showing them the way out of our state.”

With over 23,000 lending stores in the U.S. (more than Starbucks and McDonalds combined), payday loans represent a $59 billion a year industry. Its critics argue that it is a form of predatory lending that targets young and low-income workers. People in need of quick cash—usually a few hundred dollars—bring in their pay-stub, fill out paperwork and turn over a personal check post-dated two weeks later and written for the amount plus the “loan fee”. What many people don’t understand is that the fee is actually the annual interest rate. According to the North Carolina Department of Justice “payday loans may seem like a quick solution to a cash crunch, they’ll cost you a lot more in the long run. A payday loan of $100 to $500 can carry an annual interest rate of 390 to 780 percent. Payday loans are due in full on your next payday, typically in two weeks. If you aren’t able to repay the loan that fast, as most borrowers aren’t, you can get stuck on a debt treadmill. This happens when borrowers, unable to repay the loan, take out new loans or rollover the old one. You pay the fees on your loans over and over again, without ever being able to pay off the loan.” 

New York, Georgia and 11 other states followed North Carolina and also banned them. Undeterred, the biggest players simply shifted operations and went online. Any attempt at meaningful Federal legislation from Congress was met with fierce lobbying efforts from groups such as the “Community Financial Services Association” and the “Online Lenders Alliance.” Both groups represent the payday loan industry.

To date, Rogers has taken corporate/PAC donations (which are reported separately from individual/personal donations) from:

Community Financial Services Association—Alexandria, VA—- $5,000
Advance America Cash Advance Centers, Inc.—Spartanburg, SC—$2,500. Advance America is the largest chain of payday lenders in the U.S.

Rogers also took donations from the following individuals:

Lindsay Webster—Owner, Advance America, Spartanburg, SC—$1,250
William Webster IV—Chairman and Director, Advance America, Spartanburg—$1,250

Vincent K. Ney—CEO of GECC, Bergheim, TX—$2,500——- Background on Ney:  GECC are the initials of “Government Employees Credit Center, Inc.” is a Texas-based payday loan operator. Here’s a link to a press release from the West Virginia Attorney General: . The headline: AG McGraw sues GECC and Dollar Financial for $3.9 million for continuing to make illegal internet payday loans.

Mark E. Curry gave $2,500. FEC law requires candidate to report a donor’s name, address and occupation for anything above $50. Rogers reports Curry lives in Las Vegas, but for Curry’s occupation Roger’s states “Information Requested.” However, our research has found a Mark E. Curry in Vegas who owns a collection agency (Smith, Haynes and Watson, LLC) that works for several payday loan shops. In 2011 Curry and his collection agency were in litigation with the AG of Maryland. Link:  .Here is a story from a Baltimore paper with more:

Our research also shows that a Mark E. Curry was formerly the chairman of the Online Lenders Alliance.

Tim Rupli—“Executive” at T.R. Rupli & Associates, McClean VA—$1,000 ….. Rupli runs a boutique lobbying firm that apparently only represents one client: The Community Financial Services Association. According to U.S. Senate records from 2008 Rupli spent $230,000 lobbying on behalf of CFSA. . Link:

Joshua S. Landy—$1,500—No employer listed—Miami FL …..  Watchdog groups that track campaign financing show he donates to a lot of campaigns across the country. Some of these candidates’ FEC reports list his occupation differently, but include: U.S. Money Shops, National Processing Centers, and “President” of ACA (American Cash Advance).

Why is a candidate from NC attracting and accepting so much money from an industry banned in NC?


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Jake Frankel
Jake Frankel is an award-winning journalist who enjoys covering a wide range of topics, from politics and government to business, education and entertainment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

11 thoughts on “Bothwell slams Rogers over payday loan industry donations

  1. indy499

    Cecil getting desperate. Not a surprise. Torn between the obvious preference which is for him to lose and what may be the better choice—- 1 of 435 house seats with little power versus 1 of 7 city council members.

  2. wncguy

    Bothwell is always “slamming” and attacking. How about spending sometime on what you will do as a congressman. He and his supporters seem to be angry about something and want to go on the attack.

    • Dionysis

      “How about spending sometime on what you will do as a congressman.”

      He has; of course, that means you’ll have to spend some time reading the positions he’s been advocating for a while now, but if that is too much trouble, here are some for you:

      *public financing of all political campaigns.

      *to create jobs today through federal spending: a renewal of the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) that bailed out so many families following the Great Depression

      *funding public elementary education and approval of the ERA. It also necessarily includes science-based environmental protection so we leave our children a living planet

      *adopting a modified form of what is known as the Fair Tax

      *implement a Financial Transactions Tax on stock, bond and other securities trades, and an estate tax on large estates.

      *concur with the international panel on drug policy which has just submitted a report to the United Nations recommending an end to the global war on drugs.

      *renegotiate global trade deals including NAFTA and CAFTA to include worker and environmental protection

      *introduce a public option to the recently enacted health care legislation and then move toward a single-payer system.

      *eliminate corporate personhood

      His positions on other topics can be easily found by opening one’s eyes and expending minimal effort.

  3. Dionysis

    Mr. Whalen attempts to downplay the criticism, and turns his attention on unrelated matters to impugn Bothwell, but chooses to ignore the fact that this pernicious, predatory ‘industry’ is helping to fund his candidate.

    Mr. Whalen, is Bothwell’s charge true or not? If it is, then just why are such campaign contributions being accepted and what is the quid pro quo? They’re not contributing to Mr. Rogers because they like his face.

  4. The payday loan industry provides a valuable (and obviously needed) service to poor people while progressive public policy erects barriers to prosperity. Thanks for being there, loaners, when we need you.

    • bill smith

      SRLY? Seriously? Loaning money to people at a ridiculously high interest rate that in the long run only further cements their economic shortfalls *helps*?

      Seriously? Or are you just being a contrarian?

    • Dionysis

      What kind of Objectivist are you anyway? Your goddess, Ayn Rand, said herself of the poor:

      Poverty is a punishment from society for being lazy. Rand herself said, “Why are those poor people so lazy? Look at me, I’m rich, white, and I have no mental handicaps, all because of what I’ve accomplished.”

      And you include yourself among the poor that “need” the loan ‘industry’?

      Since the payday loan ‘industry’ exploits the neediest and most desperate, the only ones that can possibly prosper are those who run these “valuable” services. If you can factually identify one case where a poor person was able to rise from his surroundings and “prosper” as a result of the benevolence of the loan ‘industry’, please share it. I take it you are not an example.

  5. Barry Summers

    “The payday loan industry provides a valuable (and obviously needed) service to poor people…”

    So do people who buy children. Damn those progressives and their unfair barriers to the child slavery/prostitution/snuff-film entrepreneurs.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.