Dunkeld and Birnam become Asheville’s newest sisters

Representatives of the committees from Dunkeld and Birnam in Scotland and Asheville join Rep. Susan Fisher and Mayor Esther Manheimer at a ceremony recognizing the new relationship between the cities on Sept. 10. Oscar Wong, Highland Brewing Co. founder, is also pictured. Photo by Michael Oppenheim

The small Scottish cities of Dunkeld and Birnam recently became Asheville’s latest international siblings, with events in Scotland Aug. 18-20 and a ceremony in Asheville on Sept. 10. Over five years in the making, the new relationship adds a seventh pairing to Asheville’s formal Sister Cities relationship roster, joining Vladikavkaz, Russia; San Cristóbal de las Casas, Mexico; Saumur, France; Karpenisi, Greece; Valladolid, Mexico; and Osogbo, Nigeria.

At the Asheville ceremony, Mayor Esther Manheimer officially welcomed delegates from the two communities in Perthshire, Scotland and signed a proclamation declaring the special relationship that now exists between Asheville and Dunkeld and Birnam. Rep. Susan Fisher also attended the event at Highland Brewing Co.

At a celebration on Aug. 19 in Scotland, National Public Radio’s Fiona Ritchie said, “This twinning follows years of planning, and a weekend of intense dedication, from many residents of our community who were excited about the potential of the twinning invitation we’d received from Asheville. We’re looking forward to building all sorts of connections for the benefit of both communities, as we have so much in common.” Ritchie, who founded and hosts NPR’s The Thistle & Shamrock, also serves as chair of Dunkeld and Birnam Friends of Asheville, N.C., the group behind the effort to develop the sister cities’ agreement.

Some cities in Europe refer to the process of forming a relationship with a city in another country as “twinning,” explains Karon Korp, president of Asheville Sister Cities.

According to Asheville Sister Cities representative Rick Lutovsky, “There is a growing interest in developing this sister city relationship drawing upon our many common characteristics and interests: the considerable Scottish ancestral roots throughout the Southern Appalachians; parallel economic characteristics such as art, music, recreation and tourism; the striking physical beauty of our two settings; education; health affairs including an holistic approach to wellness; a strong sense of community; the Presbyterian (Church of Scotland) heritage; and, an abiding love of nature and commitment to stewardship of the surrounding physical environment.”

A press release from Asheville Sister Cities, with significant input from Ritchie, outlines even more reasons the two locations are especially copacetic:

It all makes perfect sense when you have a browse through the history books. In the 18th and 19th centuries, Scots-Irish immigrants heavily settled the Asheville area. They seeded a music tradition throughout the Southern Appalachians, along with many other customs. The Annual Grandfather Mountain Highland Games, held near Linville (northeast of Asheville), can’t quite boast the longevity of the Birnam Games (founded in 1864). It does, however, date back more than 60 years and is one of North America’s most renowned Highland gatherings, drawing crowds of 30,000 across four days of events. The spectacular mountain setting secures its reputation as one of the best celebrations of Scottish culture in North America. Asheville is also the site of Biltmore House, America’s largest private home. Built by George Washington Vanderbilt between 1889 and 1895, and still owned by his descendants, the French-style renaissance castle has stunning views of the Blue Ridge Mountains and the French Broad River. Overlooking the River Tay, the 15th-century Murthly Castle near Birnam will make for a fascinating “twin” across the miles and the centuries.

Much more connects the contemporary communities. Ashevillians sometimes refer to their city as “Foodtopia” and it is home to dozens of local tailgate markets, all selling farm-fresh produce and artisan goods from bakers, cheese makers and more who all converge each week to provide the best in locally sourced produce. Dunkeld and Birnam’s community orchard and organic growing project “The Field,” along with its seasonal stalls and “Fieldfare” work-for-food project, are a reflection of a community spirit that these “Soul Sisters” share.  And for real ale enthusiasts, Asheville is proud to claim more breweries per capita than any other U.S. city.

Western North Carolina and Perthshire are each known worldwide for their spectacular autumn colors. Western North Carolina has a tremendous variety of trees; the Smoky Mountains hosts 120 species, the greatest variety anywhere in the United States. Like Dunkeld and Birnam’s Perthshire Amber and Niel Gow Festivals, Asheville also shares a particular passion for music, from the traditional songs and tunes brought to the area by Scotch-Irish settlers, to the legends of what was once called “mountain music”: Jimmie Rodgers, Doc Watson and the Steep Canyon Rangers. They have all contributed to Asheville’s vibrant cultural scene where Old Time, Bluegrass, Celtic and singer-songwriter scenes thrive.  Many are taught and performed through the summer months at the nearby Swannanoa Gathering folk arts workshops. Celebrating its 26th anniversary this year, the Gathering has already hosted participants from Dunkeld and Birnam.

For more information, visit the Facebook group for supporters of the Dunkeld and Birnam connection with Asheville or www.ashevillesistercities.org.

All photos by Michael Oppenheim


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

7 thoughts on “Dunkeld and Birnam become Asheville’s newest sisters

  1. BLM

    That St. Andrew’s cross flag reminds me of the confederate flag, I am shocked and offended that Asheville’s leaders would join as a sister city to a country that flies such a hateful, racist-looking flag. I have been officially triggered by this hideous macro-aggression…also notice that there were no “people of color” in any of the pictures!?!?! Hmmm…and Mr. Wong doesn’t count, he’s of Asian, not African descent.


    • Big Al

      Want more reason to be “offended?”

      That “rampant lion” flag draped on the table is the official symbol of the royal family of Scotland (which, since 1703 is also the royal family of the United Kingdom) and should only be displayed with the express permission of the Queen of England. If this permission was not requested and granted, then Asheville has just insulted Her Majesty and all of her subjects.

      Also, that NC flag hanging behind the table is an 1880s revision of the first NC flag that was specifically created for Confederate troops to carry into battle. NC had no state flag prior to 1861. The new flag, like most Confederate monuments, was a conciliatory measure between the white supremacist southern Democrats and the equally racist northern Republicans who needed southern cooperation to allow Federal troops to pass through and be quartered in the south prior to the imperialist American invasion of Cuba (to kill those pesky Catholic latinos) in the 1890s. Therefore, ALL NC state flags are either Confederate flags or symbols of shared northern-southern post-reconstruction WASP supremacy.

      Of course, these are all silly gray areas that nobody cares about today, but are still examples of how just about ANY symbol or memorial in America can, if you think hard enough about it, “trigger” somebody’s weepy wussy zone.

      • C-Law

        Big Al, you get my vote for top-10 best responses ever on mtnx!

        Great job revealing yet again that for the cultural marxists facts are to be ignored in the interest of pushing the Hegelian dialect. I suspect that is also why they are so comfortable making strange bedfellows with jihadi Mohammedans–they both are masters of practicing taqqiyah!

    • Dr. Jam

      The St. Andrews Cross national flag of Scotland (saltire) dates from 1180, preceding the confederate flag by 681 years (see full comment below).

  2. bartley tuthill

    it makes sense to me. asheville is as wonderful as dunkeld and birnam. go see for yourselves, you’ll nay be sorry fa it!

  3. Dr. Jam

    Historical notes for those commenting here!:
    * The St. Andrews Cross national flag of Scotland (saltire) dates from 1180, preceding the confederate flag by 681 years. It may actually date to the 9th century as a symbol of a united Pictish and Scots army. It represents St. Andrew who was crucified on an X-shaped cross. He is the patron saint of Scotland as his relics were brought there. Sad that such an ancient flag would “trigger” something so relatively recent, repugnant and not Scottish. It is known, and flown, internationally as a proud symbol of Scotland and will outlast the other flag you mention long into future centuries.
    * The Dunkeld and Birnam signing event was attended by the Lord Lieutenant, the Queen’s regional representative, so we can assume permission was granted to use the Lion Rampant flag on the table!
    * FYI – Queen Anne (1665 – 1714) was the last “Queen of England”. In 1707 the Acts of Union united her realms as a single sovereign state known as Great Britain. The saltire is a component part of the UK flag – the Union Jack – if you take a look.
    Good day to all!

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.