OPINION: Foie gras ban a waste of energy

Foie gras is created by the practice of “gavage” to a duck or goose until its liver is inflated to a nice, ripe, plump, delicious size. It’s a delicacy, enjoyed for centuries and a food that very nearly saved culture back when it was a peasant food in ancient Egypt around 2600 B.C. It originated as a “throw away” organ that slaves would feed their families since their masters under-fed them. Realizing they could fatten their crop and eat the leftovers, the farmers developed what would eventually become the appetizer of kings, as soon as they snatched that too from their starving workers.

But despite its cultural relevance, this stalwart of culinary culture has come under attack again recently, including in Asheville. These efforts are not because foie gras is unnecessarily cruel, unethical or unhealthy, but because it is an easy target for extremists who are against the raising of animals for the purpose of eating them and who think that if it looks uncomfortable to humans, then it must be so for the animal. They struck first in Chicago — which eventually lifted its ban on the fatty pate — and more recently in California. That state’s ban kicked in July 1; a direct slap in the face to cultural icons like Thomas Keller of the French Laundry who used foie gras to define modern American cuisine.

So what is all the fuss about? Why are animal rights activists in such a tizzy about an appetizer that on any given day less than 1 percent of the population is eating? It’s because these birds, mostly raised cage free for the first nine weeks of their lives, are force fed (gavage) for the last two to three weeks before they are slaughtered. In other words, these geese and ducks are raised in way better conditions than the chicken you ate for lunch at Applebee’s, and in way less stressful conditions than they would face in the wild (see this video from Anthony Bourdain).

For the last two weeks of their life, the geese are fed like kings (something that some farms in California have been doing naturally, without the controversial 30-second tube feedings), until they are fat and happy and ready to be prepared for our eager and respectful tables. Not only that, but chefs like Keller and other obsessive geniuses in California have gone so far as to make sure that their birds were raised at higher standards than most Kobe beef (and Waygu Kobe are massaged daily and fed beer!).

As an animal-rights supporter, as an environmentalist, as someone concerned about the well being of all living creatures and who still considers himself an evolutionary product, a hunter, a carnivore and a lover of all things fleshy — there is a part of me that understands why people who don’t eat anything with a face might have an issue with foie gras.

But you are wasting your energy. You are sparring with the puppies when you should be fighting the wolves. If you are someone who wants to truly help with the rally for the ethical treatment of farm-raised animals, I am all about that and fully support of you, but it does not start with foie.

That fight starts with boneless, skinless chicken at your local grocery store. It starts with Chicken McNuggets, Zaxby’s and KFC. In 2007 McDonalds sold $5.2 billion worth of chicken alone, and all of those animals were raised in the most horrible conditions imaginable. Yet we are arguing over foie gras, an industry that raises just $72 million in total annual sales globally, what McDonalds might make selling chicken in just one county for a year.

The horrors of factory-farmed chicken, beef and pork are blatant and extremely well documented. Most of the companies that do abuse their foie geese are the same companies that manufacture these animals. Not to mention that factory farming is a global industry with ties to the uses of carcinogenic steroids and chemicals to increase production. At any given moment over three quarters of our population is chowing down on a chemical-laden, minced-up version of a factory farmed animal.

That’s 233,693,938 people. At that same moment, 1,000 might possibly be eating a pate of foie gras. Trying to stop the production of foie gras is like swinging a fly swatter at a single, specific hornet when you are standing in the middle of a hornets’ nest. If you really want to end cruelty in foie gras production, stop factory farming and you will be left with the heavily regulated and ethical foie gras that most high-end restaurants already serve.

Let’s dispense with the distractions and focus on what really matters: ethical, local, organic meat. Let us turn that energy towards the promotion of local farmers and local fisheries. Let’s take our money, our resources and our voices and lend them to our neighbors. Let’s keep our wallets closed to the factory farms that produce the sorry excuses for meat they serve our kids in schools. Let’s eat real food from real farms, Let’s ban boneless, processed meats.

And let’s shut the hell up about foie gras.

Asheville resident Jonathan Ammons is a local bartender, musician and food aficionado


Thanks for reading through to the end…

We share your inclination to get the whole story. For the past 25 years, Xpress has been committed to in-depth, balanced reporting about the greater Asheville area. We want everyone to have access to our stories. That’s a big part of why we've never charged for the paper or put up a paywall.

We’re pretty sure that you know journalism faces big challenges these days. Advertising no longer pays the whole cost. Media outlets around the country are asking their readers to chip in. Xpress needs help, too. We hope you’ll consider signing up to be a member of Xpress. For as little as $5 a month — the cost of a craft beer or kombucha — you can help keep local journalism strong. It only takes a moment.

About Jonathan Ammons
Native Asheville writer, eater, drinker, bartender and musician. Proprietor of www.dirty-spoon.com Follow me @jonathanammons

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

9 thoughts on “OPINION: Foie gras ban a waste of energy

  1. Dionysis

    Whether one agrees with the writer or not, the piece is thoughtful, logical and well-written.

    Still, issuing pronouncements about where the “fight starts” (it starts where any individual wishes it to start) and to “shut the hell up…” are unnecessary, and not your call to make.

  2. marytully

    I’m thinking the author didn’t get the memo that nearly all of the Asheville restaurants targeted in the ban, source their foie gras from Hudson Valley Foie Gras out of New York, one of the biggest factory foie gras farms in the country.

    Hudson Valley Foie Gras has a beautiful website. In fact, that’s where I first saw Anthony Bourdain’s video touting the humanity with which foie gras is produced. Of course, Hudson Valley cannot legally say that they humanely produce their foie gras, not after the Better Business Buruea admonished their competitor for making such false claims, and while several restaurants and chefs are in litigation for making such false claims. They can, however, post a video of Bourdain saying that all foie gras production in humane in his opinion, so that’s what the let him make such claims for them.

    So which is it? Do we, or do we not like factory farms? I just don’t see how we can have it both ways. If a chicken factory farm is bad, then isn’t a duck factory farm just as bad? Hudson Valley Foie Gras has as dubious a factory farm record as any other factory farm, complete with its share of cruelty investigations and federal Clean Water Act violations (HVFG was convicted of over 1000 violations to te Clean Water Act for dumping slaughter waste and animal waste into New York’s waterways), and Lexington Avenue Brewery admitted–no bragged–that they sourced the foie gras hey served at their Craggie Brewery Dinner earlier this month, from Hudson Valley Foie Gras.

    I’m all for preserving culture, but what about Asheville’s culture? Can we tout our commitment to our local farm-to-table movement, while simultaneously importing environmental devastation and cruelty? It’s a valid question. After all, a factory farm is a factory farm, and environmental devastation in New York sends its ripples through all of our communities. The author asks if foie gras is really worth targeting in a ban, when so few restaurants serve it. I believe the same can be asked of him: Is foie gras really worth defending, when it’s production involves cruelty and pollution, and no one is feeding their hungry families with it? Methinks the foodie doth protest too much.

  3. annono.

    If you are opposed to foie, you cannot support factory farming. Bottom line.

  4. Emry

    “You are sparring with the puppies when you should be fighting the wolves.”

    I think that sums up your article nicely. Great job, Jonathan!

  5. Amy Jay

    Mr. Ammons never says that he thinks Fois Gras is a great thing, he simply says that the zealous attack of it is kind of pointless, which I agree with. How much fois gras is eaten on a regular basis, compared with how much fast food chicken is eaten? That’s what (I believe) he is trying to point out. I think people see the word “fois gras” and go blind with rage and are unable to see the underlying point the author is trying to get across. While I don’t agree with every word said, I certainly agree with the gist of the article, and believe it to be well-written.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.