Also dogged by doubt

When I read Cecil Bothwell’s article on Lucia Del Vecchio’s new play, Athena [“Dogged by Doubt: Actors Face Huge Hurdles in NC Stage Catalyst Production,” Aug. 8], my jaw dropped. Literally, not figuratively. Was this meant to be a review? Mr. Bothwell certainly seemed to be exercising a lot of critical judgment.

I’ve never heard of a theater critic reviewing a production on the basis of reading the script before the production opens. Would Ken Hanke review a new movie by reading the screenplay without seeing it? Would your music critic review a musician’s debut of a new album by reading the score and not listening to the CD? (Can your music critic read a score?) Even experienced play readers don’t see (and hear in their mind’s ear) what an experienced and imaginative theater director (not to mention playwright) may.

There’s a famous story that when Peter Shaffer was circulating the manuscript of a new play in the early 1960s (this was long before Amadeus), potential producers laughed at Shaffer’s stage direction about the Spanish conquerors of Peru: “They climb the Andes.” They didn’t laugh when director John Dexter turned Royal Hunt of the Sun into one of the most thrilling productions of the decade.

You’ll need to send someone else now to review Athena. Mr. Bothwell has compromised his objectivity on this one.

— Arnold Wengrow

Writer Cecil Bothwell responds: When offering a preview of a world-premier play, one has very little to go on other than the script and the reputation of the director and players. As a playwright and actor in numerous productions since the mid-1960s, I believe I have some basis for critical judgment of a script—though I fully acknowledge that my opinion is only that. And as noted in my piece, the Asheville track record of those cast in Athena suggests they are fully capable of pulling a surprising rabbit out of a somewhat limp scriptural hat.

About Webmaster
Mountain Xpress Webmaster Follow me @MXWebTeam

Before you comment

The comments section is here to provide a platform for civil dialogue on the issues we face together as a local community. Xpress is committed to offering this platform for all voices, but when the tone of the discussion gets nasty or strays off topic, we believe many people choose not to participate. Xpress editors are determined to moderate comments to ensure a constructive interchange is maintained. All comments judged not to be in keeping with the spirit of civil discourse will be removed and repeat violators will be banned. See here for our terms of service. Thank you for being part of this effort to promote respectful discussion.

4 thoughts on “Also dogged by doubt

  1. MarDivPhoto

    The comments made by Mr. Wengrow are right on the mark, and the defensive reply by Mr. Bothwell is exactly that. No matter what one’s supposed experience is in an art, the proof of the pudding is in the tasting, not in looking at the recipe. Mr. Bothwell insists on continuing to disparage the play (“a somewhat limp scriptural hat”) on the basis of his perception of the script, and that is unfair to the playwright. The audience last night found it quite stimulating and moving, as the lights went up even some male members of the audience were observed wiping their eyes. However, it’s now a good bet that no matter what, Mr. Bothwell will manage to find things he doesn’t like about this work. His objectivity is indeed compromised.

  2. chris

    I saw this show on Tuesday night and thought it was very well done all around.

    As an avid theatergoer and reader of reviews here in Asheville and in the other cities in which I’ve lived, I’ve never before seen a writer preview a show based on a script. I can’t see any point in giving whatever further review he writes of this show any credence, be it good or bad.

  3. From Cecil’s article:

    “Watch for the Xpress review on our A&E;blog on Aug. 16.”

    I’m watching, but I don’t see it. Where is it Cecil? You’ve set yourself up for this one, you should at least deliver the goods.

Leave a Reply

To leave a reply you may Login with your Mountain Xpress account, connect socially or enter your name and e-mail. Your e-mail address will not be published. All fields are required.